200 Rhodora [OcroBER 
expanded his botanical appendix, adding 15 pages and 24 numbers 
to his list and revising his descriptions; second, that the Gray Herb- 
arium reprint is from the first edition; and, third, that there is a 
typographical error in the Index Kewensis citation, which should 
read p. 29. 
Most authors have probably followed Hooker in citing Richardson, 
but some libraries have the reprint from the first edition and others 
from the second while still others have only one or other of the 
complete volumes of Franklin's Narrative, with the original paging 
in the appendix. It would be advisable, therefore, in citing publi- 
cation of those species listed in edition 1 of Franklin’s 1st Journey to 
cite both editions with original page numbers and to include both 
reprint page numbers also. For example, Crepis nana Richards. 
Frankl. Journ. App. ed. 1 (1823) p. 746 (18 in rep.); ed. 2 (1823) p. 
757 (29 in rep.).—E. B. Bascock. 
Vol. 26, no. 309, including pages 169 to 180, was issued 30 September, 1924. 
