KOSA PINIPINELLIFOLlAxRUBIGlNOSA IN ABERDEEN 107 



Some names are certainly used in a significance different from that 

 given in Mr. Rogers' " Handbook." 



R. suberectus, And. 77, 100; R. affinis, W. and N. (as var. of 

 rhamnifolius) ) 86 ; R. Lindleianus, Lees (as var. of rhamnifolius), 

 17 ; R. incurvatus, Bab. (as var. of rhamnifolius), 98, 100; R. 

 Tillicaulis, W. and N. (as var. of carpinifolius), 77, 100; " R. 

 carpinifolius, Blox.," given as a synonym of " umbrosus, Arrh.," 

 and thus very uncertain as to its true name, 77, 100 ; R. mac- 

 rophyllus, W. and N. (as a variety of " R. discolor, W. and N.), 

 77 ; R. mucronatits, Blox. (as var. mitcronulattis, Bor. of R. 

 carpinifolius, Blox.), 7 7 ; R. radula, Weihe (as a variety of 

 R. glandulosus, Bell), 77, i oo ; R. echinatus, Lindl. (as var. 

 rudis, Weihe, of R. glandulosus, Bell), 100 ; " R. glandulosus, 

 Bell," 98, 100; R. dumetorum, W. and N. var. diversifolius, 

 Lindl. (as a variety of R. carpinifolius, Blox.), 100; var. 

 tuberculatus, Bab. (as variety of R. carpinifolius}, 76, 77 ; R. 

 Koehleri, W. and N. (as a variety of R. glandulosus, Bell), 76, 

 100; R. ccesius, L., 76, 77. 



In Sonntag's "Flora of Edinburgh" (1894), the following are 

 mentioned in addition to those noted above, viz. R. suberectus, And., 

 83, 85 ; R. carpinifolius, Blox., 83, 85 ; R. glandulosus, Bell, 82, 

 83, 86 ; R. echinatus, Lindl., 83 ; R. Koehleri, W. and N., 83, 84, 

 86 ; R. ccesius, L., 83. 



In Mr. P. Ewing's " The Glasgow Catalogue of Native and 

 Established Plants," 1899, several forms are noted under districts 

 not noted above, a number of them with a query : R. suberectus, 

 And., "75, Smith? 99, Watt?; R. Lindebergii, P. J. Muell, "100, 

 King?"; R. villicaulis, Koehl., 77? 99 Watt, 101 Ewing?; R. 

 pubescens, Weihe, 103 Ewing ; R. macrophyllus, W. and N., 102 ; R. 

 rosaceus, W. and N., 97, no?; R. Koehleri, W. and N., 98 

 King?, 99 Watt?, 100?; var. dasyphyllus, Rogers (as pallidus, 

 Bab.), 99?; " R. fusco-ater, Weihe," 98 Druce ? ; R. corylifolius, 

 Sm., 98 King ?, 99 Watt ?, 102 Ewing ?, 103 Ewing ?; R. 

 ccesius, L., 77 Ewing ?, 97 Ewing ?, 98 King ?, 99 Watt ?, TOO 

 King ?, i o i Ewing, no Somerville ?. 



ROSA PINIPINELLIFOLIA x RUBIGINOSA 

 IN ABERDEENSHIRE. 



By W. BARCLAY. 



IN the 'Notes on Aberdeenshire Roses' which appeared in 

 the "Annals of Scottish Natural History" in January 1902, 



