CONCERNING THE SUPPRESSED BOOK. 437 



I have. Merely stating that the affair is purely the affair of the Messrs. Apple- 

 ton, and that not even a thought about money ever entered my head concerning 

 it, I draw attention to the readiness with which Mr. Harrison, without a particle 

 of evidence, makes grave insinuations. And I do this because it will enable the 

 reader to judge what need there probably was for taking the measures I did to 

 prevent the wider and more permanent diffusion of Mr. Harrison's misrepre- 

 sentations. 



Concerning the newspaper extract describing a Comtist service I know 

 nothing, and greatly regret that it was appended. I will at once ask to have it 

 withdrawn. If three gentlemen, appointed in the usual way, decide that under 

 the circumstances, as stated to me by Professor Youmans, I was not justified in 

 the course I took, I will, if Mr. Harrison wishes it, request Messrs. Appleton to 

 suppress the book and destroy the stereotype plates, and I will make good their 

 loss to them. 



I am, faithfully yours, HERBERT SPENCER. 



May 29. 



[Times, June 2d.~\ 

 MR. SPENCER AND MR. HARRISON. 



To the Editor of the Times. 



Sir : I will not pursue this matter further, nor will I insist on Mr. Spencer's 

 fair offer to submit it to arbitration. It satisfies me if he will not claim any 

 absolute and moral right to copyright in America my writings with rectifications 

 of his own. I am accustomed to unauthorized reprints of what I write ; and as 

 I hear there is a brisk sale for these essays {quorum pars minima fui) I will only 

 congratulate the Yankee editor on his 'cuteness. As Mr. Spencer, by his offer, 

 now admits it to be possible that he made a mistake, I am ready to regard his 

 share of it as an inadvertence. I know too well his great generosity in money 

 matters to suppose that any question of profit crossed his mind. But it certainly 

 crossed some one's mind ; and I referred to it only to convince him that eager 

 partisans had led him into a mistake. It is not easy at any time to get him to 

 see this, and to open his eyes I used for once plain words. Conscious that I had 

 conducted a philosophical debate with an old friend with all the deference and 

 admiration that I really feel for his genius, it did pain me to find myself treated 

 as the proverbial dog whom any stick is good enough to beat. The only arbi- 

 tration I now desire is that of some common friend who may convince him that 

 I wish nothing more than a return to the position of philosophic friends who 

 agree to differ about their respective systems. 



I am, &c, 



June 1. FREDERIC HARRISON. 



[Times, June 3d.] 

 MR. SPENCER AND MR. HARRISON. 



To the Editor of the Times. 



Sib : Rather than have any further question with Mr. Harrison, and rather 

 than have it supposed that I intentionally ignored his copyright claim, I have 

 telegraphed to Messrs. Appleton to stop the sale, destroy the stock and plates, 

 and debit me with their loss. 



I am, faithfully yours, 



Clovelly, June 2. HERBERT SPENCER. 



