fflSTORICAL ACCOUNT OF EVOLUTION THEORY 27 



former paper of Wallace. TKe ideas were expressed under the title 

 On the Tendency of Varieties to Depart Indefinitely from the Original 

 Type, and it proved to be an unusually concise and lucid statement of 

 the main points of the natural-selection theory. Darwin at once 

 wrote to Lyell as follows: 



"I never saw a more striking coincidence; if Wallace had my 

 MS sketch, written in 1842, he could not have made a better short 

 abstract ! Even his terms now stand as heads of my chapters. Please 

 return to me the MS which he does not say he wishes me to pubUsh 

 but I shall, of course, at once write and offer to send it to any journal. 

 So all my originality, whatever it may amount to, will be smashed, 

 though my book, if it ever have any value, will not be deteriorated, 

 as all the labour consists in the appHcation of the theory, I hope you 

 will approve of Wallace's sketch, that I may tell him what to say." 



Lyell insisted that Darwin publish an abstract of his own work 

 simultaneously with ttat of Wallace, and this course was carried out. 

 Darwin's generosity was equaled by that of Wallace who wrote, in 

 1870: 



"I have felt all my life and still feel the most sincere satisfaction 

 that Mr. Darwin had been at work long before me, and that it was not 

 left for me to attempt to write The Origin of Species. I have long 

 since measured my own strength and know well that it would be quite 

 unequal to the task." 



Still later he wrote: "I was then (and often since) the 'young 

 man in a hurry,' he [Darwin] the pamstaking student, seeking ever 

 the full demonstration of the truth he had discovered, rather than to 

 achieve immediate personal fame. " 



One must perforce admit the nobility of character of both men; 

 but there can be no serious competition between the two for the honor 

 of being called the originator of the natural-selection theory. 



CONTEMPORARY OPINION REGARDING THE VALIDITY OF DARWIN'S VIEWS 



At first Darwin was inclined to believe that the selection factor 

 was all-sufficient to account for the origin of species, as well as that of 

 adaptations; but as time passed he modified his earlier more sanguine 

 views and came to the conclusion " that natural selection has been the 

 main but not the exclusive means of modification." Many of his 

 followers went to such extremes in their advocacy of the all-sufficiency 

 of natural selection as would not have met with Darwin's approval. 



