216 NATURAL SCIENCE [March 



THE AUTHENTICITY OF PLATEAU MAN 



The cudgels on behalf of the Authenticity of Plateau Man have been taken up by so 

 many scientists that I only find it necessary to call attention to one paragi'aph of Mr 

 Cunnington's article in the November number of Natural Science (vol. xi., p. 327). He 

 states: " The vast number of the flint implements from the plateau gravel is another 

 difficulty. . . . We are told that two pits dug in 1894 into a bed of gravel one foot in 

 thickness yielded thousands of artificial flakes and some hundreds of scrapers. " 



Mr Cunnington is under a serious misapprehension here. It was not from the pits, 

 but from the floor on the face of the Chalk Escarpment, nearly 80 yards long, that 

 these numerous flakes were discovered. Moreover, these flakes were not those of Plateau 

 man at all, but of the late Palaeolithic man, and are of undoubted authenticity, being 

 of the ordinary form and bearing tliat hall mark of man's handiwork, the bulb of per- 

 cussion. Many have been sent to and acknowledged by Sir John Evans himself. 



If Mr Cunnington had carefully read the report to the Britisli Association, Ipswich, 

 1895, he would have seen that in reference to the plateau gravel of one foot in thick- 

 ness, my words were: "Tliis gravel was hard and compact. From it I secured very 

 many worked implements." Specimens forwarded at the time to Sir Joseph Prestwich 

 brought the reply : " Interesting, rude but true," Bex.t.^min Hakrisox. 



Igiitham, Fcby. 6, 1898. 



SOCIETK PHILOMATHIQUE DE PARIS 



In a copy of the publications of this Society, preserved in the British Museum (Natural 

 History), there is a portion of vol. i. entitled BuUetin de la SocMi Fhilomathicjiie a ses 

 correspondens, which is paged l'-119'. As I have had a good deal of trouble about the 

 date of this jiortion of the work, I may mention that in vol. iii. of Bulletin des Sciences 

 de la Society Philomathiq lie, p. 192, under tlie heading "Avis," there is a note which 

 enables us to fix the date of publication of these pages as 1803. 



C. Davies Sherborn 



( In dex A n im a limn ) . 



NOTICE 



To Contributors. — All Comnnmications to be addressed to the Editor of Natural 

 Science, at 29 and 30 Bedford Street, London, AV.C. Correspondence and Notes 

 intended for any particular month should be sent in not later than the 10th of tlie 

 preceding month. 



To THE Trade. — Natural Science is published on the 25th of each month ; all 

 advertisements should be in the Publishers' hands not later than the 20th. 



To OUR Subscribers and Others. — There are now published Tex Volumes of 

 Natural Science. Nos. 1, 8, 11, 12, 13, 20, 23, 24 being out of print, can only be 

 supplied in the set of first Four "N'^olumes. All other Nos. can still be supplied at One 

 Shilling each. 



Priceof Setof Vols. L, II., III., IV £2 10 



„ v., VI., VIL, VIII. . .14 

 „ L— VIII 3 10 



One Shilling each Number of any Bookseller. 



Annual Subscription, payable in advance to J. M. Dent & Co., 29 and 30 Bedford 

 Street, London, W.C„ Thirteen Shillings ($3-50), post free. 



9> 



