﻿226 
  MARINE 
  MOLLUSCA 
  DESCRIBED 
  BY 
  P. 
  P. 
  CARPENTER 
  

  

  MonUiopsis 
  rhines 
  (Dall), 
  Dall, 
  1919, 
  U. 
  S. 
  Nat. 
  Mus., 
  Proc., 
  vol. 
  56, 
  no. 
  2288, 
  p. 
  28, 
  

  

  pi. 
  8, 
  fig. 
  5 
  

   Clathrodrillia 
  (MonUiopsis) 
  rhines 
  Dall, 
  1921, 
  p. 
  70; 
  Oldroyd, 
  1924, 
  Pub. 
  Puget 
  Sound 
  

  

  Biol. 
  Station, 
  vol. 
  4, 
  p. 
  76, 
  pi. 
  5, 
  fig. 
  4 
  figure 
  obscure, 
  difficult 
  to 
  determine; 
  1927, 
  vol. 
  II, 
  

  

  pt. 
  1, 
  p. 
  74 
  

   MonUiopsis 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter), 
  Graxt 
  and 
  Gale, 
  1931, 
  p. 
  565 
  D. 
  cancellata 
  in 
  part 
  

   Clathodrillia 
  rhines 
  (Dall), 
  Keen, 
  1937, 
  p. 
  33 
  

   OphiodcruicUa 
  rhines 
  (Dall), 
  BuRcn, 
  1946, 
  no. 
  62, 
  p. 
  10 
  

  

  "Drillia* 
  cancelhita, 
  ? 
  n.s. 
  Like 
  the 
  voung 
  of 
  iiicisa, 
  but 
  nodosely 
  cancellated." 
  [Car- 
  

   penter, 
  1864b, 
  p. 
  658J 
  

  

  "*A 
  peculiar 
  group 
  of 
  .species, 
  resembling 
  ClioncUa 
  (Marine, 
  testa 
  Sfinipson)." 
  

  

  Carpenter's 
  description 
  (1865) 
  of 
  this 
  species 
  was 
  republisiied 
  by 
  Oldroyd 
  (1927) 
  under 
  

   Clathrodrillia 
  rhines 
  Dall. 
  The 
  following 
  line 
  should 
  be 
  added 
  to 
  complete 
  that 
  copy: 
  

  

  "Hah. 
  In 
  sinu 
  Pugetiano 
  duo 
  specimina 
  legit 
  Kennerley: 
  quorum 
  altero 
  labium 
  sub- 
  

   callosum, 
  altero 
  planatum." 
  [Carpenter, 
  1865e, 
  p. 
  63] 
  

  

  Dall 
  renamed 
  Drillia 
  ca)icellata 
  Carpenter 
  because 
  he 
  considered 
  there 
  were 
  turrids 
  with 
  

   the 
  same 
  specific 
  name. 
  However, 
  the 
  original 
  names 
  otlier 
  tlian 
  Carpenter 
  were 
  : 
  

  

  Pleurotoma 
  cancellata 
  Eichwald, 
  1830, 
  Nat. 
  Lithuaen, 
  p. 
  225; 
  Deshayes, 
  1834, 
  Descrip. 
  

   Coq. 
  foss. 
  Paris, 
  II, 
  p. 
  474; 
  Calcaka, 
  1839, 
  Ricerche 
  Malac, 
  p. 
  5 
  ; 
  H. 
  C. 
  Lea, 
  1841, 
  

   Amer. 
  lour. 
  Sci., 
  vol. 
  XL, 
  p. 
  98; 
  (Sowerby), 
  Wood, 
  1842, 
  Ann. 
  Mag. 
  Nat. 
  Hist, 
  vol. 
  

   IX, 
  p. 
  542; 
  Gray 
  in 
  Reeve, 
  1846, 
  Icon 
  Conch., 
  vol. 
  I, 
  Pleurotoma, 
  pi. 
  XXXV, 
  fig. 
  317. 
  

   See 
  Sherborn, 
  1924, 
  Index 
  animalium, 
  pt. 
  V, 
  p. 
  1033 
  

  

  These 
  would 
  not 
  preoccupy 
  Drillia 
  cancellata 
  Carpenter. 
  That 
  is, 
  Carpenter's 
  name 
  is 
  

   not 
  a 
  primary 
  homonym. 
  Until 
  any 
  of 
  the 
  turrids 
  of 
  the 
  previously 
  named 
  cancellata 
  is 
  

   placed 
  in 
  the 
  same 
  genus 
  as 
  Drillia 
  cancellata 
  (Ophioderniella 
  at 
  present) 
  Carpenter's 
  name 
  

   is 
  not 
  a 
  secondary 
  homonym 
  and 
  may 
  stand. 
  

  

  Dall 
  (1908; 
  1919) 
  rejected 
  the 
  name 
  as 
  a 
  secondary 
  homonym, 
  which 
  might 
  be 
  the 
  

   basis 
  for 
  the 
  validity 
  of 
  his 
  new 
  name. 
  However, 
  his 
  basis 
  ior 
  claiming 
  homonymy 
  was 
  not 
  

   correct. 
  

  

  If 
  the 
  specimen 
  which 
  Dall 
  used 
  for 
  the 
  illustration 
  of 
  MonUiopsis 
  rhines 
  (Dall) 
  (1919, 
  

   pi. 
  8, 
  fig. 
  5) 
  is 
  considered 
  not 
  the 
  same 
  as 
  O. 
  cancellata 
  (Carpenter), 
  then 
  that 
  specimen 
  

   (U. 
  S. 
  National 
  Museum) 
  would 
  become 
  the 
  holotype 
  of 
  .1/. 
  rhines 
  Dall. 
  Unfortunately 
  the 
  

   holotype 
  of 
  O. 
  cancellata 
  (Carpenter) 
  has 
  not 
  been 
  found. 
  

  

  The 
  problem 
  of 
  the 
  identity 
  of 
  this 
  species 
  remains 
  unsettled 
  until 
  analyzed 
  in 
  the 
  light 
  

   of 
  Bartsch's 
  unpublished 
  turrid 
  paper. 
  

  

  Type. 
  — 
  Not 
  found 
  

  

  Distribution. 
  — 
  Puget 
  Sound, 
  Washington 
  (type), 
  British 
  Columbia, 
  to 
  San 
  Diego, 
  

   California 
  (Burch) 
  

  

  Ophiodermella 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter) 
  

  

  Drillia 
  incisa 
  Carpenter, 
  1864b, 
  p. 
  603, 
  657, 
  658; 
  Reprint, 
  1872, 
  p. 
  89, 
  143, 
  144; 
  1865, 
  Acad. 
  

   Sci 
  Philadelphia, 
  Proc, 
  vol. 
  17, 
  p. 
  62; 
  Cooper, 
  1867, 
  (ieog. 
  Cat. 
  Moll., 
  Geol. 
  Sur. 
  Cali- 
  

   fornia, 
  p. 
  31 
  ; 
  Tryon, 
  1884, 
  Man. 
  Conch., 
  vol. 
  VI. 
  p. 
  182, 
  pi. 
  12, 
  fig. 
  41 
  

  

  T 
  arris 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter), 
  Packard, 
  1918, 
  Univ. 
  California 
  Pub. 
  Zool., 
  vol. 
  14, 
  no. 
  2, 
  

   p. 
  342, 
  pi. 
  41, 
  figs. 
  2a, 
  2b 
  

  

  MonUiopsis 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter), 
  Dall, 
  1919, 
  U. 
  S. 
  Nat. 
  Mus., 
  Proc., 
  vol. 
  56, 
  no. 
  2288, 
  p. 
  28, 
  

   pi 
  12 
  fig. 
  7; 
  Grant 
  and 
  Gale, 
  1931, 
  p. 
  565 
  in 
  part, 
  pi. 
  26, 
  fig. 
  21 
  ; 
  Baily, 
  1935, 
  West 
  

   Coast 
  Shells 
  (Keep), 
  p. 
  262; 
  Wili.et, 
  1937, 
  San 
  Diego 
  Soc. 
  Nat. 
  Hist., 
  Trans, 
  vol. 
  VIII, 
  

   no. 
  30, 
  p. 
  394 
  

  

  Clathrodillia 
  (.MonUiopsis) 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter), 
  Dall, 
  1921, 
  p. 
  70; 
  Oldroyd, 
  1924, 
  Pub. 
  

   Puget 
  Sound 
  Biol. 
  Station, 
  vol. 
  4, 
  p. 
  75, 
  pi. 
  18, 
  fig. 
  4 
  not 
  3 
  same 
  fig, 
  as 
  Dall, 
  1919; 
  

   Oldroyd 
  1927, 
  vol. 
  II, 
  pt. 
  I, 
  p. 
  72, 
  pi. 
  18, 
  fig. 
  3 
  same 
  fig. 
  as 
  Dall, 
  1919 
  and 
  Oldroyd, 
  

   1924 
  

  

  Ophiodermella 
  incisa 
  (Carpenter), 
  Bartscii, 
  1944, 
  Biol. 
  Soc. 
  Washington, 
  Proc, 
  vol. 
  57, 
  

   p. 
  62; 
  Burcii, 
  1946, 
  no. 
  62, 
  p. 
  10. 
  

  

  "Like 
  inermis: 
  spiral 
  sculpture 
  grooved, 
  not 
  raised." 
  [Carpenter, 
  1864b, 
  p. 
  657] 
  

  

  