.3,,. THE ''GRAMMAR OF SCIENCE." 457 



Professor Lloyd Morgan has himself done much admirable work 

 in a difficult field of descriptive science ; but it may be doubted 

 wliether his criticism of the " Grammar of Science " will (at any rate 

 to those who have read the book with attention) enhance the well- 

 deserved reputation which the first eleven chapters of " Animal 

 Life and Intelligence" have won for him. 



He seems to be serving two masters. If certain results are true 

 in psychology, we cannot afford to despise them when we come to deal 

 with Physics and Biology. Still less can we neglect them if we must 

 needs discuss the origin of consciousness. 



R. J. Ryle. 



