The Experimental Alethoel 7 



toward certain fields of study. As such they have often proven 

 stimulating and have been useful in acting as a guide for others. 

 But the hypothesis of real importance is the working hypothesis 

 of the investigator. It is the test by means of which he tries 

 to interpret his problem, and therefore it is essential that his 

 hypothesis is one having a practical bearing, i.e. an hypothe- 

 sis that can be shown to be true or false. It differs in this 

 essential respect from purely fictitious and from metaphysical 

 hypotheses. 



The working hypothesis carries along with it its dangers as 

 well as its advantages; since, while it may lead to discoveries, 

 it may, if it is wrong in principle, blind us to the real condi- 

 tions. Therefore the investigator must not only be an inventor 

 of working hypotheses, but cultivate also a skeptical state of 

 mind toward all hypotheses — especially his own — and be 

 ready to abandon them the moment the evidence points the other 

 way. And herein hes one of the differences between the re- 

 corder of observations and the experimenter. The work of the 

 observer, if exact, is complete in itself, and stands forever as a 

 monument to his abihty, or at least to his industry; while the 

 conclusions of the experimenter, if they are to bear fruit, must 

 become modified with each new discovery. His results are ab- 

 sorbed in the current of the next advance, but his consolation 

 will be that he has had at least a share in the causal study of 

 living things, and in helping the human race toward the control 

 of organic phenomena. 



To return to our examples. The growth of animals and 

 plants offers a wide field for experimental study. Under cer- 

 tain conditions we see a young animal continuing to grow larger 

 until a certain size is reached, when growth slowly ceases. Al- 

 though the animal may live for many years longer, it has ceased 

 to grow. What makes it grow? Why does it stop growing? 

 We have hardly begun experimental work along these fines; 

 yet we shall see later that there is a promising field for work in 

 this direction. After a time old age comes on and the animal 

 dies. We say it dies a natural death, and this seems inevitable, 



