142 



Bird -Lore 



Fish and Game Committee, and out of 

 consideration for his membership, his 

 bill was advanced and, on April 15, was 

 on the Assembly calendar for passage. 

 With Mr. Reed's consent, Mr. Francis 

 ofifered amendments, which were adopted. 

 These amendments made the Reed Bill 

 virtually the Francis Plumage Bill, better 

 known in the Assembly as the Audubon 

 Bill. When this fact was recognized by 

 the leaders of the Assembly, Mr. Phillips, 

 of Allegany county, moved a reconsidera- 

 tion of the vote, by which the amendments 

 were adopted. This motion was carried. 

 Again Mr. Francis offered his amend- 

 ments, which motion, on a rising vote, 

 was declared defeated; the vote announced 

 by the clerk being 39 to 41. Mr. Francis 

 challenged the accuracy of the count, and 

 the Chair, Mr. Hammond, of Onondaga 

 county, sustained the clerk. Mr. Francis 

 appealed from the Chair's decision, but 

 was defeated by a vote of 85 to 2, — fear 

 of the Rules Committee whijjping the 

 members into line. "Just to show Mr. 

 Francis how badly he is defeated," Mr 

 Merritt, leader of the majority, moved 

 to reconsider the vote by which the 

 amendments were lost. A roll-call was 

 taken with the following result: 



Ayes, 42 



Mamber Politics District County 



Mr. Harden Rep. Yates 



Mr. Bates Rep. 29 New York 



Mr. Bennett Rtp. 15 New York 



Mr. G. W. Brown . Rep. 4 Kings 



Mr. Callan Rep. Columbia 



Mr. Caughlan .... Dcm. i New York 



Mr. Cheney Rep. Cattauragus 



Mr. Colne Rep. 1 1 Kings 



Mr. Costcllo Dem. 5 Erie 



Mr. Donnelly .... Dcm. 13 Kings 



Mr. Edwards Rcj). 3 Oneida 



Mr. Farrar Rej). 17 Kings 



Mr. Foley Dim. i 2 New York 



Mr. Francis Rep. 23 New York 



Mr. Gillcn Dem. 2 Kings 



Mr. Goldberg Dem. 18 New York 



Mr. GoodsiK-ed . . . Rep. i Kings 



Mr. Hawlcy Rep. Franklin 



Mr. Jackson Dem. 4 ICrie 



Mr. Lanahan Dcm. Richmond 



Mr. LefTingwcll . . . Dcm. Schuyler 



Mr. Lowman Rep. Chemung 



Mr. Lupton Rep. i Suffolk 



Mr. MacOrcgor. . . Rep. S Eric 



Mr. Marlatt Rep. 2 Steuben 



Mr. Martin Rep. Seneca 



Mr. McEHigott . . . Dcm. 7 New York 



Mr. McEarlane . . . Rcj). Wyoming 



Member Politics 



Mr. Mead Rep. 



Mr. OdeU Rep. 



Mr. Oliver Dem. 



Mr. O'Neil Dem. 



Mr. Partridge Dem. 



Mr. Shea Rep. 



Mr. Sheridan Dem. 



Mr. Sullivan Rep. 



Mr. Toombs Rep. 



Mr. Weaver Rep. 



Mr. Weber Rep. 



Mr. Wende Dem. 



Mr. Williams Rep. 



Mr. F. L. Young. .Rep. 



Noes, 



Member Politics 



Mr. Allen Rep. 



Mr. Baumann .... Dem. 



Mr. Baumes Rep. 



Mr. Boshart Rep. 



Mr. C. F. Brown . Rep. 



Mr. Burhyte Rep. 



Mr. Clarke Rep. 



Mr. Cuvillicr Dem. 



Mr. DcGroot Rep. 



Mr. Eagleton Dem. 



Mr. Evans Dcm. 



Mr. Fav Dem. 



Mr. Fil'ley Rep. 



Mr. Frisbie Dem. 



Mr. Gcoghegan . . . Dem. 



Mr. Glore Rep. 



Mr. Green Rep. 



Mr. Hackett Dem. 



Mr. Hammond . . . Rep. 

 Mr. Hemenway . . . Rep. 



Mr. Howard Rep. 



Mr. Jordan Dem. 



Mr. Joseph Dem. 



Mr. Klein Dem. 



Mr. Lachman .... Rep. 



Mr. Lansing Rep. 



Mr. Lazarus Rep. 



Mr. Lee Rep. 



Mr. J. Levy Dem. 



Mr. Lowe Rep. 



Mr. Marks Rep. 



Mr. McCuc Dem. 



Mr. McGrath Dem. 



Mr. Mclncrney . . . Rep. 

 Mr. McLaughlin . . Rep. 



Mr. Merritt Rep. 



Mr. Millen Rep. 



Mr. J. L. Miller. . .Rep. 

 Mr. VV. G. Miller. Rep. 

 Mr. F. J. Murphy. Rep. 



Mr. Neupert Dem. 



Mr. Nolan Rep. 



Mr. F. B. Parker... Rep. 

 Mr. J. S. Parker . . Rep. 

 Mr. C. W. Phillips Rep. 

 Mr. J. S. Phillips. .Rep. 

 Mr. Robinson .... Rep. 



Mr. Rozan Dem. 



Mr. Sanner Dem. 



Mr. Sargent Rep. 



Mr. Schmidt Dem. 



Mr. Scott Rep. 



Mr. A. E. Smith. . . Dem. 



Mr. C. Smith Rep. 



Mr. F. L. Smith. . .Rep. 



