CHAPTER IX 

 The Pigeon Butcher's Defense 



By E. T. Martin, from the "American Field," Chicago, 

 January 25, 1879. 



The preceding chapter by Prof. H. B. Roney in American Field, was 

 answered by E. T. Martin, a game dealer of Chicago, who afterwards issued 

 a pamphlet, the first page of which is herewith reproduced, and I make 

 quite extensive extracts from the body of the circular, which incidentally 

 advertises Martin as "the largest dealer in live pigeons for trap shooting 

 in the world, also a dealer in guns, glass balls, traps, nets, etc." 



I call the reader's attention to the following: 



In the table given of the shipments from Petoskey and Boyne Falls, 

 etc., during 1878, Martin estimates the number shipped alive from 

 Cheboygan as 89,730, yet H. T. Phillips of Detroit, shows from his 

 records that he alone shipped from that point 175,000 that year. So if 

 Martin's estimates are all as far wrong as this one, he should account for 

 a total shipment of over 2,000,000 pigeons. 



In Martin's circular, he seems to take offense at some remarks Prof. 

 Roney has made in this article that reflect upon the character of these 

 netters, for Martin uses in quotation marks the following: "A reckless, 

 hard set of men, pirates, etc.," which seems to have some foundation in fact, 

 as Martin says: "In proof of the pigeons feeding squab indiscriminately, 

 I may mention the fact that one of the men in my employ this year, while 

 at the Shelby nesting in 1876 in one afternoon shot and killed six hen 

 pigeons that came to feed the one squab in the same nest." Further 

 comment is unnecessary. — W. B. M. 



A LITTLE after the middle of March a body 

 of birds began nesting some twelve miles north 

 of Petoskey, near Pickerel Lake. About April 

 8 another and larger body "set in" along Maple and 

 Indian Rivers, and Burt Lake, and near Cross Village, 

 there being in all some seven or eight distinct nestings, 



93 



