11. DUINKWATKR 



239 



Nos. II ,111(1 12. Frank and James Hcrbi'rt; one stndied under 

 Dr Arnold .if Winchester Cathedral, and the other at Wells Cathedral. 

 Both obtained first-class uuisieal a|i]iiiint.nients ( l'niless(irslii|is) in the 

 United States. "Frank's wife was not of a niiisieal family, but she was 

 a cievi'r literary writer." 



No. I'.i. Anne, musical. 



Nos. 14 and 1.5. Mary and Emily, were both musical. 



No. 16. Henry, was for some time orpuiist at Crcsforii. Later hi; 

 entered the medical proft^ssion. He and 



No. 17. Alfred are ' full of the blood of the old ones." Alfred later 

 took to law'. 



No. lis. Wife of Alfred, is clever nnisically. 



No. 10. Kate 1 



No. 20. Clara J 



Gmei-atiun V. 



No. 1. Musical. 



No. 2. " Among the best." 



No. 3. Music teacher by profession, " is e.xccedingly clover." She 

 is "a public })erformer." 



Nos. 4 and 5 are very gifted. 

 Generation VI. 



No. 1 is very gifted. 



I am able to give the pedigrees of four other musical families. In 

 the E. D. and to a less extent in the R. family the ability is of a very 



)th musical performers. 



INHERITANCE OF MUSICAL ABILITY. R. F.\milv. 



It agrees with the theory that where both parents are 

 musical all the children should be musical. 



rrr 



c? cJ ? 



9 rf = 9 



?=rf 



I 1 1 



? = (? 



? i 



1 



?=rf t=i ? = rf ? ? ? 



6 i i 



