NO. 3 OPINIONS 82 TO 90 33 



' A / Catalogue / of the Animals and Plants / represented in Catcsbj-'s 

 Natural History of Carolina : / With the Linnacan Names.' / 



" About the legitimacy of these names there can be no dispute. The editor 

 realizing that Catesby's names — even when consisting of one generic and one 

 trivial name only — had no nomenclatorial standing, deliberately and success- 

 fully set about to remedy this defect. 



"As I understand the present " Opinion " its intention is only to eliminate 

 the names given by Catesby." 



Remarks by Secretary : Commissioner Bather's siiijgestion in- 

 volves only editorial revision and has been complied with. 



As respects Commissioner Hartert's reservation. Opinion 20 is 

 not before the Commission in this vote. As he does not specifically 

 vote against the Opinion, his name is carried with a ? both under the 

 concurring" and the not voting Commissioners. In either case this 

 does not inflttence the ultimate result. 



Commissioner Stejneger's reservation is interpreted bv the Secre- 

 tary as limiting the unanimous vote of the Commission in the case of 

 Catesby 1771 so that the suspension does not include the concordance. 



