NO. 5 OPINIONS 98 TO 104 3 



In summary he found that, rigidly construed, i^rauer and Bergen- 

 stamni did not fix the types for the older generic names, except in the 

 cases where they distinctly state that the species mentioned is the type 

 of the genus. 



The findings were unanimously approved hy the 8 Commissioners 

 and Alternates present, namely : Apstein, Bather, Ilartert. Jordan 

 (K.), Muesebeck. Rothschild, Stejneger, and Stiles. 



Later, the case with Commissioner Jordan's conclusion was sub- 

 mitted in Circular Letter No. 127 to all absent Commissioners. The 

 final vote stands as follows : 



Opinion concurred in by fifteen (15) Commissioners: Apstein. 

 Bather, Chapman, Dabbene, Hartert, Horvath, Jordan (D. S.), 

 Jordan (K.), Kolbe, Loennberg, Neveu-Lemaire. Stejneger, Stiles, 

 Stone. Warren, and two (2) Alternates, Muesebeck and Rothschild: 

 Total 17. 



Opinion dissented from by no Commissioner. 



Not voting two (2) Commissioners: Handlirsch, Ishikawa. 



