244 



THE JOURNAL OF BOTANY 



which seems to suggest that Andrews's relation to the work was 

 regarded as pecuHar. Nor does it seem necessary to cite the 

 references to Kennedy in connection with the first five volumes, 

 as his responsibility for these has already been showm. 



The references other than those to Andrews and Kennedy are 

 mostly derived from Salisbury's publications, among which I 

 include Knight's ProteecB, the botanical portion of which is doubt- 

 less rightly attributed to him.* In matters of this kind, as indeed 

 wdienever personal animosity is not concerned, Salisbury was, as 

 I have shown elsewhere,! very accurate, and his attributions are 

 the result of actual knowledge. It is, however, somewhat strange 

 that although the names quoted in the Proteece are usually attri- 

 buted to Andrews, a few, as will be seen, are credited to Haworth. 



Tab. Vol. VI. 



365 Scilla siberica (sic) ... Haw. 



376 Neottia minor... ... Kenn.j 



388 Mesembryanthemum Haw. 



inclaudens 



391 Nymphaea Lotus ... Blandf. 



408 Dahlia pinnata ... Haw. 



414 Larochea falcata ... Haw. 



421 Eenealmia calcarata ... Haw. 



429 Protea incurva ... Haw. 



Haw. Suppl. PI. Succ. 80,n. 

 Salisb. in Trans. Hort. Soc. 



i, 291. 

 Haw. Syn. PI. Succ. 295. 

 Description signed H. 

 Text accompanying plate. 

 Salisb. in Tr. Hort. Soc. 



i,91. 

 Haw. Syn. PI. Succ. 50. 

 ("How") Salisb. in Tr. 



Hort. Soc. i, 281. 

 Knight Prot. 17. 



437 Protea canaliculata 

 473 Yucca gloriosa 

 475 Serapias cordigera 



501 Hellenia Allughas 

 521 Eriospermum folioli- 



ferum 

 528 Ornithogalum elatum 

 532 Veronica Derwentia ., 



538 Vanilla planifolia 



540 Mesembryanthemum 

 heterophyllum 



Vol. VII. 



,. Haw. 

 ,. Haw. 

 .. Jacks. 



Vol. VIII. 



.. Jacks. 

 Jacks. 



Jacks. 



Little- 

 john 



Lam- 

 bert 



Jacks. 



Knight Prot. 46. 

 Haw. Suppl. PI. Succ. 36. 

 Sahsb. in Tr. Hort. Soc. 

 i, 290. 



Sahsb. op. cit. 281. 

 Salisb. Gen. 15. 



29. 

 R. Br. Prodr. 434. 



SaUsb. in Tr. Hort. Soc. 



i, 295. 

 Haworth Syn. PL Succ. 



221. 



* See Journ. Bot. 1886, 297. 



t Journ. Bot. 1912, Suppl. iii, 4. 



I But the description is signed " IJ." 



Haworth, 



