U3 



APPENDIX TO ARGUMENT. 



No. 3. 



BemarJcs on the United States Evidence. 



Any detailed criticism on tlie United States evidence must, of neces- 

 sity, Jbe reserved for oral argument, but there are some observations 

 bearing- upon the character and reliability of sucli evidence which it is 

 deemed j)roper here to put before the Arbitrators. 



In the first place, it must be pointed out tliat the assertions made in 

 respect to seal life and other connected subjects in the United States 

 Case, are entirely based on very recent affidavits, or on papers which 

 have been specially obtained or j)repared in connection with the present 

 discussion, and which are now jiroduced for the first time. Further, 

 that many of these are derived from persons who formerly occupied 

 official i^ositions in connection with the management or supervision of 

 the Pribyloff Islands under the United States Government control, 

 and who were the authors of official Keports and other writings on the 

 condition of the islands; but that such earlier and public official 

 Keports are not now^ referred to in the United States Case. The fol- 

 lowing Table shows the names of the Agents and Officials whose sworn 

 evidence appears in the United States Appendices, and which also 

 shows their previous Keports and writings: 



144 Ifames of Wit- 

 nesses. 



Ch. Bryant . 



Stephen N. Buynitsky 



William H. Dall 



Captain M. A. Healy 

 John A. Henriqucz; . . 



Ahial P. Loud 



H. H. Mclntyre 



Keports, Evidence, or pnhlished "Writings, for- 

 merly made by Witnesses. 



John M. Morton 



Jacob H. Moulton. - - . 



Jost'ph Murray 



S. K. I^ettleton 



H.G.Otis 



Benjamin F. Scribner 

 William H. "William.s 



Milton Barnes 



Henry A. (Jlidden 



Ch.J.Goff- 



Sen.. 41st Cong.. 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 32; H.E., 

 41st Cong., 3rd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 122; H. R., 

 42nd Cong., 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 20; H. R., 

 44th Cong., Ist Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 83; "Mouo- 

 giapli of North American Pinnipeds," p. 381 et 

 seq.; "On Eared Seal.s," p. 381. 



H.K. ,41st Cong., 3rd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 122, p. 5; 

 H. E., Ex. Doc, 44th Cong., 1st Sess., No. 83: 

 H. R., 50th Cong., 2nd Sess . Rep. No. 3SS3, p. 1. 



"Alaska ana its Kesonrces," Chap. VI 



Where Reports 



relened to in 



United States 



Case. 



Sen.,4l8t Cong., 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 36; H. R., 

 50th Cong., 2ud Sess., Rep. No. 3883, p. 116. 



11. R., i)Oth Cong., 2nd Sess., Rep. No. 3883, p. 250. 



Sen.,5Ist Cong.,2ud Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 49 



Sen., 51st Cong., 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 49 



S. Falconer 



Louis Kimmel . . . . 



T.F.Rvan 



W.B.Taylor 



George Wardmaa. 



H. R., 50th Cong., 2ud Sess., Rep, No. 3883, p. 17. . . 

 Sen., 5l8t C(mg., 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 49 ; letter 



to Mr. Windom, British Counter-Caso. App., 



vol. i, pp. 84, 85. 

 H. R., 42nd Cong., 2nd Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 20, p. 2; 



H.R. ,44th Cong., 1st Sess., Ex. Doc. No. 83. 

 H. i;., 50th Cong., 2nd Sess., Rep. No. 3883, p. 267 



Ibid., p. 211 



Ibid., p. 41 



Ibid., p. 20 



Fnitfd States 

 Ci.se, p. 153. 



1877 



1872 



1880 

 1891 

 1869 

 1889 

 1889 



1878 

 1884 

 1«91 

 1891 

 1881 

 1880 

 1891 



1885 

 1890 



1876 



1883 

 1886 

 1881 



1885 



115 



