4 THE VOYAGE OF H.M.S. CHALLENGER 
present to arrive at a definite decision as to the true position of Goniopecten. The diffi- 
culty is further increased by Perrier himself remarking on the interesting link afforded 
by this form between Astropecten and the Pentagonasteride (oc. cit., pp. 166, 250). 
Whilst refraining from criticising in any carping spirit Studer’s excellent description 
of Inidiaster,* which is stated by him to be an aproctuchous form with aborted supero- 
marginal plates, and ranked accordingly amongst the Astropectinide, I cannot escape 
from a strong suspicion, aroused by the consideration of the general characters of this 
interesting asterid, that when a further supply is available for study the genus Luidiaster 
may also find a place in the family Archasteridz, The absence of the superambulacral 
plates (‘‘epiambulacral ” of Studer) is in direct support of this view. It would be inte- 
resting to know whether the papule are distributed over the abactinal surface or limited 
to special areas at the base of the rays. The general facies of the form leads me to infer 
that the latter will probably be the case, although this inference is purely conjectural, 
for I have no positive basis on which to make such a generalisation. 
Subfamily PararcHAsTERIN#&, Sladen, 1886. 
Genus Pararchaster, Sladen. 
Pararchaster, Sladen in Narr. Chall. Exp., 1885, vol. i. p. 610.* 
Disk small. Rays very long, tapering, and flexible. 
Marginal plates suboval or triangular, elongate in the direction of the ray, confined to the 
margin of the ray, the two series alternating more or less, Each plate with a prominent boss. 
Supero-marginal plates with one long cylindro-conical spine, and sometimes a companion 
present. Infero-marginal plates with one or more similar spines. The general surface of the 
plates of both series is nominally naked, or only with minute isolated spiniform thornlets. 
A large odd interradial plate is present in both marginal series, the superior one with 
a prominent boss and a very large spine at the summit of the interbrachial are. 
Abactinal area with squamiform plates covered with skin, bearing one to three or 
more spicules or minute spinelets. No true paxille. No definite order of arrangement. 
Papule confined to an area at the base of the ray. 
Actinal interradial areas with very few intermediate (ventral) plates. In some cases 
these are apparently wanting altogether; and are generally absent in young forms. 
Armature of adambulacral plates consisting of :—(1.) a semicircular furrow series of 
small uniform spines, radiating fan-like; and (2.) one or more large conical outer spines 
on the actinal surface. 
Madreporiform body close to the odd interradial marginal plate. 
Peculiar comb-like pedicellarize frequently present. 
1 Sitzungsb. naturf. Freunde Berlin, 16. Oct. 1883, p. 131; Anhang z. d. Abhandl. d. k. preuss. Akad. d. 
Wiss. Berlin, vom Jahre 1884, p. 46, Taf. iv. figs. 7, a, b, c, d. 
2 The Notes published in the “ Narrative” of the voyage were in type in July 1884. 
