representative. So let Mr. Caine's table stand, as I thoroughly adopt it, 

 and that after personal careful examination. Such a class in Liverpool 

 must have influenced a far larger circle than even that of the Essayists, 

 and must, when conducted as Mr. Caine has evidently conducted it, 

 prove a real quickening and encouragement to many young minds. 



I am, my dear Sir, 



Yours cordially, 



WILLIAM GRAHAM. 



1st Class. — Distinguished. 

 Hiram Tatter sail. 

 Fred. Broadbridge. 

 John Smitton. 



1st Class. 

 Miss M. E. Osborne. 



,, F. D. Palethorpe. 



„ M. C. Palethorpe. 

 Herbert Savile. 

 Miss S. H. Thompson. 

 Ed. Watkins. 



2nd Class. 

 P. R. Palethorpe, a boy 12 years old. This 



ought to be stated on the certificate drawn up 



by Mr. Caine. 

 W. J. Banks. 

 H. V. Cantrell. 

 H. A. Keily. 

 Miss Sarah Kendall. 

 A. Maddock. 

 J. Watkins. 



P.S. — I adopt this table of the relative merits of the Essayists as 

 substantially correct and just. I do so after careful independent reading 

 and inspection. 



(Signed) WM. GRAHAM, D.D., 



Adjudicator. 



