( xvii ) 



end of the rains I found both models and mimic scarce, but 

 Concordia the more common of the two. This, however, was 

 in lower and flatter country, whereas the Crenis, especially 

 the large blue ones, are particularly addicted to hills." 



Dr. F. A. UiXEY said that to deal with Mr. Marshall's 

 criticisms point by point would require another treatise on the 

 same scale as the one now before them. He therefore pro- 

 posed to reserve any detailed comment for a future occasion. 

 In the meantime he wished to thank Mr. Marshall for his 

 courtesy in allowing him to see the paper before it had been 

 communicated to the Society. He welcomed the opposition 

 therein offered to his own view, because no theory could claim 

 to stand on a firm basis until it had been well scrutinised and 

 had run the gauntlet of adverse criticism. The author of any 

 hypothesis that had been successfully attacked had always the 

 satisfaction of feeling that at least he had helped to arouse 

 interest and to stimulate inquiry ; and in any event the cause 

 of truth would be the gainer. No doubt they had from Mr, 

 Marshall as good a statement of his side of the case as any one 

 could make, and if his objections could be satisfactorily met, 

 as in the speaker's opinion they could be, it was not likely that 

 any more formidable assault would have to be faced. It would 

 naturally be expected that he should join issue with Mr, Mar- 

 shall, and this he undertook to do when the time came ; 

 meanwhile he would only make the general remark that ajyriori 

 reasoning in similar matters had before now been known to 

 fail, even when aided by mathematical processes as unimpeach- 

 able as those of his present critic. 



SPECIAL GENERAL MEETING. 



Wednesday, February 5th, 1908. 



Mr, C, 0. Waterhouse, President, in the Chair, 



Projiosed Alteration of a Bye- Law. 

 The Secretary read the following notice communicated to 

 the President and Council of the Society, and read at three 

 previous meetings in accordance with the Bye- Laws. 



PROC, ENT, see, LOND,, II. 1908, B 



