BRACHIOPODA. 433 
Orthis (Hebertella) borealis.] 
OrtHis (HEBERTELLA) BOREALIS Billings. 
Fig. 33. Orthis (Hebertella) borealis Billings. a, dorsal; 6, ventral, and e, profile view of a variety 
of this species. Upper part of the Galena shales near Wykoff, Minnesota. Collection of E. O. Ulrich. 
1859. Orthis borealis Brnuines. Canadian Naturalist and Geologist, vol. iv, p. 436, fig. 14. 
1863. Orthis borealis BILLINGS. Geology of Canada, p. 129, fig. 56; p. 167, fig. 148. 
1873. Orthis borealis MEEK. Palxontology of Ohio, vol. i, p. 101, pl. vit, fig. 4. 
1875. Orthis borealis Mtuter. Cincinnati Quarterly Journal of Science, vol. 2, p. 28. 
1889, Orthis borealis NETTELROTH. Kentucky Fossil Shells, p. 36, pl. xxxtv, figs. 14-20. 
1892. Orthis (Hebertella) borealis HALL. Paleontology of New York, vol. viii, pt. i, p. 222. 
The Minnesota specimens of this species are closely related to Orthis plicatella 
of the Galena horizon, so that a detailed description is not necessary. They can be 
distinguished from each other by the fold and sinus, in O. borealis, being on the 
dorsal and ventral valves respectively, while in O, plicatella the cofiditions are the 
reverse. These differences are not so pronounced as in specimens from the Ohio 
valley, where O. borealis usually has, in addition, a much deeper dorsal than ventral 
valve. The latter character is one of the chief distinctions between Prof. Hall’s 
subgenera Hebertella and Plectorthis, and is developed at its maximum in (0. sinuata 
Hall. From the preceding it is readilly seen that these subgenera probably had 
their origin in the Chazy formation, and there and in the Trenton are not easily 
distinguishable, but in the Hudson River group of the Ohio valley Hebertella is one of 
the characteristic markers of that horizon, there reaching its maximum of growth, 
diversity and number of individuals. Plectorthis also attains its maximum in the 
Hudson River group, the tendency in the Cincinnati group being towards diminished 
size, but greater numerical strength and irregularity of plications, while in the north- 
west the radical form developed into other distinct, large, somewhat localized species. 
Hebertella persists into the Upper Silurian, while Plectorthis, which probably origin- 
ated first, became extinct with the Hudson River group. 
Formation and locality.—Rare in the upper Clitambonites horizon of the Galena shales near Wykoff, 
Cannon Falls and top of West St. Paul bluffs, in Minnesota. Prof. Whitfield mentions its occurrence in 
Wisconsin. Very common near the top of the Trenton limestone at Frankfort, Burgin, Lexington and 
elsewhere in central Kentucky. Near Nashville, Tennessee. In Canada Billings cites it from the Chazy 
to the Trenton at Caughnawaga, St. Genevieve, Isle Bizard and Cornwall. 
Collectors.—K. O. Ulrich and C. Schuchert. 
