228 ERYTHEA. 
Don also described another pine from the same locality, 
“near the sea at Monterey,” under the name of Pinus tuber- 
culata, the description being in the same volume, on the 
same page just beneath the description of P. radiata, and not 
before it on page 441, as usually quoted. The leaves are 
wanting as in the other, but rightly supposed to be in threes. 
“Qones oblong with unequal sides, four inches long, two and 
one-half thick, scales quadrangular truncate, those at the 
exterior base larger and conical, with an elevated apex.” 
The trees are described as like those of preceding species, 
and Don adds: “Found by Coulter along with the preceding, 
which it resembles in size and habit, but essentially distin- 
guished by the form of its cones.” All these terms accur- 
ately describe a small-coned form of Monterey pine. 
Another pine should be referred to in this connection: 
Pinus Sinclairi, Hooker and Arnott in the Botany of Beechey’s 
Voyage, p. 392, (1840,) which is described as found abun- 
dantly at Point Pinos, near Monterey. A beautiful figure 
accompanies the description of a cone shaped like that of the 
Monterey pine, but over 12 inches long! Dr. Engelmann, 
who examined the specimens in the Kew herbarium in 1879, 
writes in the Botany of California, Vol. II, p. 128: “Pinus Sin- 
elairi, Hook. & Arn., is a factitious species founded upon 4 
cone of P. Montezume and the foliage of P. insignis, Douglas, 
while P. radiata of the same authors (notlof Don) is made up 
of the foliage of the former species and cone of the latter.” 
Mr. Lambert in his Prnvs, 3rd ed., iii, 133, fig. 86, 1842, 
deseribed Pinus radiata, quoting Don’s language, and added 
a good figure of a large cone, presumably the one upo? 
which Don based his description. 
Mr. Loudon, two years later, published in his ARBORETUM 
Don’s name and description, also giving a good but reduced 
figure. 
Mr. Loudon, also in the same volume, publishes fully our 
tree, giving its characters of trunk, fruit, foliage, etc., adding 
figures of a middle-sized cone and of the seeds and 
leaves—the latter much twisted—all under a name assigné 
