CANADA, PARLIAMENT OF. 8 91 



Mr. Girouard's amendment was then nega- Ste. Marie, Scriver, Semple, Somerville. Thompson, 



tived on the following division: Trow Turcot, Waldie, Watson, Weldon (Albert), 



, r -.,, Welsh, Wilmot, Wilson (Ehrin). Wilson (Lennox), 



YEAS Bam (Soulanges) Baker, Bergeron Cargill, Wood (Westmoreland), Wright, Yeo-91. 



Car ing, Caron (Mr Adolphe), Chisholm Choquette, NAYS Armstrong, Bain (Soulanges), Bergin, Bow- 



Cockburn Costuran, Coughlm, Coulombe, Couture, ell Brown, Bryson, Burns, Cargillf Carling, Carpen- 



Curran, Daoust, Davis, Denison, Dcsaulniers Des- tel% Sir Adolphe Caron, Casey, Chisholm, Cockburn, 



ris on iiset Gautlner Girouard Grand- /-<*: n ---- i,i:_ /-i_.!i v. /~i ----- Rii_ -r^ ----- J 



iardins, Dupont, iiset, Gautlner, Girouard, Grand 



, ^.,,^1., ^v/u^.uuon , * t,i*;iy u v ^o^,, 

 Popc -Robertson (Hastins) Small Th6nen, Ward, 



;vin, Livingston, Sir John Macdonald, McDowall, 

 xjCulla, McDonald (Victoria), McDougald (Pictou), 



iiUJJ^rV, .nilLLOl/lUlJ^, ^iUUCD, JJUlli V " OUU- |V| ^ 



worth), 

 Borden, 



y f. \ . ' -. rj- '.' ~f- . Wiiov/ii IAJOOVAI, J. CIICY I X1..->O11J1 UUia f , A Cl 1C V IWUtilVVil/, 



ter, Cartwright (Sir Richard), Casey Casgrain, Chart- Pope) Porter) Riopel5 Rob ertson (Hastings), Roome, 



1 Hill I, VnMlUvvi VJO*Jiil IVU* VlMBIUm VJtlli.lU.Ul . UIX/VI UWU.L. 



Gordon, Guillet, Hale, Hesson, Hickey, Holton, 



Innes, lves, Jamieson, Joncas, Jones, Kirk, Kirkpat- Mr. Jamieson's main motion was negatived 



Barren, Borden. 



rick, Landry, Lantr, Langclier (Quebec), Laurier, O n the following division : 



Lavergne. Lovitt, Macdonald (Huron), McCulla, Me- ,,. 



Donald (Victoria), McDougald (Pictou), Mclntyre, YEAS Bam (Wentworth), Baird, 



McKay, McLelan, McMillan (Huron), McMullen, Me- Bourassa, Boyle, Brien, Bryson, C-... r v ~^ u ,, 



Neill, Madill, Mallory. Mara, Matwon, Mills (An- Charlton, Cimon Clayes, Colby, Cook Couture, 



napolis), Mills (Bothwell). Moncreiff, Montague. Mu- P avie V D , e St - Georges, Edgar. Edwards, Eisen- 



lock, O'Brien, Patersou (Brant), Perley (Assmiboiaj, hauc j' F^her, Foster, Freeman Gillmor, Hale, Hol- 



Perley 

 Purcell 

 Robertson 



ner, Smith (Ontario^Some r^i 'lie, Sproure7ste\-ensou, (A'ssiniboia) Perry, Platt Porter, Purcell, 'Putnam, 



Taylor, Temple, Thompson, Tisdale, Trow, Tupper gl>eitson (King's, P. E. I ), Robertson (Shelburne), 



(Pictou), Turcott, Tvrwhitt, Waldie Wallace, Wat- Koome, Scnver, Semple, Shakespeare, Smith (Onta- 



son, Weldon (Albert), Welsh, White (Cardwell), >), Som ^ r r v J 1 J e< b / t ?^ nson 'J?W or 4 TT TF cot ' Waldie , 



White (Renfrew), Wilmot, Wilson (Argenteuil), Wil- -Watson, Weldon (Albert), Welsh, White (Renfrew), 



son (Elgin), Wilson (Lennox;, Wood (Westmore- W , d . m l ot N Wl H (Lennox), Wood (Westmoreland), 



landl Wriffht Yeo 136 Wright, Yeo 70. 



lUJJia ;. TT 1 Iti lit. JL CV A t>U. -kT A 11 -i-* ft~t i N -w- i 



NATS Amyot, Audet, Bain (Soulanges), Baker, 



Mr. Sproule then moved in amendment: Bechard, Bergeron, Bergin, Bemier, Bowell, Brown, 



That all the words after " That " be struck out of Burns Cameron, Cargin, Carling, Sir Adolphe Ca- 



the main motion, and the following substituted: "In *? n > Carpenter, Sir Richard Cartwright, Casey, 



the opinion of this House, when it is found expedient Casgrain, Chisholm, Choquette, Cockburn, Costigan, 



to prohibit the sale and manufacture of intoxicating ou 7 rnh ?' Coulombe, ^urran, Da y, Daoust, .Davm, 



liquors, it shall be accompanied by a reasonable meas- avis : P*wi Denison, Desaulmers Desjardins, 



lire of compensation to those who invested their Deasamt, Doyor^ Duchesnay Dupont. Ellis, Fergu- 



money in the trade under the sanction of the law." ?. n (Leeds and Grenyille), Ftset, Gautlner, Geofirion, 



Gigault, Girouard, Gordon, Grandbois, Guay, Guil- 



Mr. Fisher moved in amendment to this bault, Guillet, Haggart, Hall, Hesson, Hickey, lves, 



amendment : Jones, Kenny, Kirkpatrick, Labelle, Labrosse, Lan- 



Thatall the words after "That" be struck out, 

 and the following inserted in lieu thereof: " the 



Mr. Fisher's sub-amendment was carried on O'Brien, Patterson (Essex), Perley (Ottawa), Pope, 



thp following division Prefontame, Reid, Rmfret, Riopel, Robertson (Hast- 

 ings) Robiilard, Ross Ste. Marie, Scarth, Skinner, 



YEAS Amyot, Audet, Bain (Wentworth), Baird, Small, Sproule, Temple, The"rien, Thompson, Tis- 

 Barron, Be'ohara, Bergeron, Bernier, Borden, Bou- dale, Trow, Tupper (Pictou), Tyrwhitt, Vanasse, 

 rassa, Boyle, Brien, Cameron, Campbell (Kent), Sir Wallace, Ward, Weldon (St. John), White (Card- 

 Richard Cartwright, Casgrain, Charlton, Choquette, well), Wilson (Argenteuil), Wilson (Elgin), Wood 

 Cimon, Clayes, Colby, Cook ? Couture, Davies. De St. (Brockvillc) 112. 

 Georges, Dosaulniurs, Dessamt, Dovon, Duchesnav, -v, 



Duront, Edirur. E.lwurds, Eisenhaucr, Ellis, Fisdt' Disallowance of Manitoba Railway Acts. Mr. 



Fisher, Foster, Gauthier, Geoffrion, Gigault, Gillmor, Watson moved that Mr. Speaker do now leave 



Guay, Hale, I [niton, Innes, Jamieson, Jones, Kirk, the chair for the House to go into Committee 



L ;,T l! 7' H ng ' . Lan p lier (Montmorency), of the Whole, to consider the following pro- 



Langelier (Quebec), Launer, Lavertrne, Lovitt, Mac- . ,,-n , ..o..*/, 



donald (Huron), Melntyre, McMillan (Huron), Me- POsed resolutions : 



Mullen, Mallory, Mills (Annapolis), Mills (Both- 1. That under the terms of union each of the prov- 



welli, Mitchell, Mulock, Paterson (Brant), Perry, inces of the Dominion as existing in 1881, at the time 



Platt, Prtfontaine, Purcell, Putnam, , Robertson of the confirmation by Parliament of tlio charter 



(King's 1 J . E. I.), Robertson (Shelburne), Robiilard, granted to the Canadian Pacific Railway Company, 



