2396 NORTH ATLANTIC COAST FISHERIES ARBITRATION. 



Elder, Honorable Samuel J. Continued. 

 Questions 3 and 4 Continaed. 



"Report" and "entry": Distinguished: 1545; imperial statute, 1775, B.C. 

 Ap., 54S, 1545-6. United States never claimed exemption from, for trading 

 vessels, 1546. 



Report: Forced, case of Everett Steele, U. S. C. Ap., 842, 1552. Imprac- 

 ticable to, danger of ice, 1549. Ought not always to be required, 1551-3. 

 Should not be required where shelter is sought, 1552. Sufficient to prevent 

 smuggling, 1547. When physically possiWe, provided in modus vivendi 

 of 1906 and 1907, 1549. 



Shelter, no report should be required in case of, 1552. 



Smuggling: An abuse of treaty right, FTTZPATRICK, 1547. Report sufficient 

 to prevent, 1547. 



Statutes cited: Imperial, 1775, B. C., Ap. 643, "report" and "entry" dis- 

 tinguished, 1545-6. 



Trading vessels, exemption from entry and report, United States never 

 claimed, 1546. 



Treaty right, smuggling an abuse of, FITZPATRICK, 1547. 

 Question 6, pp. 1553-1577. (July 22, 1910.) 



American, Franco-, dispute, 1821-4, 1568-9. 



Amherst, Port, the Mascot ordered out of, 1572. 



Anderson v. Anderson, 1895, 1 Q. B., 749, words to be used in their usual 

 sense, 1564-5. 



Bathurst to Hamilton, June 21, 1819, B. G. Ap., 99, Americans expected to 

 fish in bays on west coast, 1567. 



Bayard, case of the, 1572. 



Bayard, West to, Mar. 19, 24, 1886, U. S. C. Ap., 755, notice not to fish in 

 British North American territorial waters, 1573. 



Bayard to West, Mar. 23, 1886, U. S. C. Ap., 755, notice not to fish in Brit- 

 ish North American territorial waters, 1573. 



Bayard-Chamberlain treaty, U. S. C. Ap., 39-40, delimited bays on non- 

 treaty coast only, 1573. 



Bays: Americana expected to fish in, on west coast of Newfoundland, Bath- 

 urst to Hamilton, June 21, 1819, B. C. Ap., 99, 1567. Americans fished 

 therein in 1820-1, 1568-9. Americans fished in, address of Newfoundland 

 Assembly to Queen, 1846, U. S. C. Ap., 1072-3, 1570. Included in 

 "coast:" British proposal for treaty of 1818, B. C. Ap., 88, 1556-7; New- 

 foundland Assembly Report, 1845, U. S. C. Ap., 1068, 1565; Scotch her- 

 ring fisheries act of 1867, 1559. Omitted from 1818 treaty altogether, 

 contention of Bond, 1575. On nontreaty coasts only delimited by Bayard- 

 Chamberlain treaty, U. S. C. Ap., 39-40, 1573. Right to use expressed, 

 Senate Committee Report, B. C. Ap., 436, 1573. Used differently in 

 treaties of 1783 and 1818, 1554. 



Beale, pp. 74, 133, 302, 525, words to be given natural meaning, 1564. 



Bond's contention: Absurdities of, 1575-6. Bays omitted from 1818 treaty 

 altogether, 1575. 



Bond's distinction between ''coast" and "coasts," 1555, 1558. 



Bonne Bay, case of the Bayard in, 1572. 



Boyle to Lyttleton, Apr. 15, 1904, U. S. C. C. Ap., 338, Americans entitled 

 to winter fishery, 1575. 



British proposal for treaty of 1818, B. C. Ap., 88, "coast" included "bays," 

 1556-7. 



Canada admitted American rights to coasts, Halifax Commiseion, 1571. 



Canada, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



