INDEX TO ORAL ABGUMBNTS. 2405 



Ewart, John S., K. C. Continued. 

 Question 1 Continued. 



Liberties, colonial, in fishery: 1369-71. 1620, Virginia charter, right of King 

 to give fishery monopoly disputed, Sabine's report, U. S. C. Ap., 1166-70, 

 1369. 1691, Massachusetts charter, right of free fishery reserved to British 

 subjects, 1369-70. 1699, Imperial statute, free fishing not unlimited, 

 1371-2. Colonial charters enumerated, fishing liberties, 1370-71. Colo- 

 nial charters, laws regulating fisheries under, B. C. Ap., 770-76, 1370-1. 

 Colonial fishing rights covered in 1783 treaty by "free fishing," 1372. Free 

 fishing in 1783 treaty, means freedom previously enjoyed by colonists, 1372, 

 did not mean unlimited fishing, 1371. Liberty to fish not license, 1371. 



Liberties in fisheries after 1783: 1390-95. Dunham v. Lamphere, 3 Gray, 268, 

 free fishing to American citizens does not prohibit State regulation, 1391-4. 



International and interstate relations, distinction, LAMMASCH, 1394-5. 



Manchester, Mass, v., 152 Mass. R. 230, 139 U. S.,240, free fishing to Ameri- 

 can citizens does not prohibit State regulation, 1394-5. 



Ownership and regulation of fisheries rested in States after 1783, 1391. 



"Liberty:" And "right," Adams to Thomas, Aug. 10, 1822, U.S. C.Ap.,S18, 

 1376. Defined, 1381-2. Does not mean license, 1371, 1381. Granted 

 United States in 1783 not exclusive, 1381, 1382. Is not right of extraterri- 

 toriality, 1382. To coast fishery, Adams' diary, Nov. 29, 1782, B. C. C. Ap., 

 103, 1377-8. To coast fishery, C. F. Adams, B. C. C. Ap., 105, 1378. 

 Used in Adams' draft 1783 treaty, 1376. 



License, liberty to fish is not, 1371, 1381. 



Livingstone to the governors, Feb. 19, 1782, B. C. C. Ap., SO, hazardous 

 position of United States in 1782, 1375. 



Livingstone to Green, Jan. 31, 1782, B. C. C. Ap., SO, hazardous position of 

 United States in 1782, 1374. 



Livingstone to Washington, Mar. 12, 1783, B. C. C. Ap., 132, right to fishery 

 is same as before Revolution, 1382. 



Local or Imperial regulations, existence of, 1404. 



Lowell, Granville to, Oct. 27, 1880, B. C. Ap., 290, joint regulations, 1425. 



Lower Canada, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



Madison to Randolph, Mar. 12, 1783, B. C. C. Ap., 132, fishery rights same as 

 before Revolution, 1383. 



Maine, statute 1883, B. C. C. Ap., 196, regulation under 1871 treaty, 1420. 



Maine, statutes of. See. Statutes cited. 



Manchester, Mass., v., 152 Mass. R. 230, 139 U. S., 240, free fishing to American 

 citizens does not prohibit State regulation, 1394-5. 



Massachusetts charter, 1691, right of free fishery reserved to British subjects, 

 1369-70. 



Mass. v. Manchester, 152 Mass. R. 230, 139 U.S., 240, free fishing to American 

 citizens does not prohibit State regulation, 1394-5. 



Monroe, Adams to, Sept. 19, 1815, B. C. Ap., 65, partition theory, 1432. 



Municipal legislation. See Local legislation. 



Negotiations, 1782: 1376-79. Adams' diary, Nov. 29, 1782, B. C. C. Ap., 103, 

 "right" to ocean fishery and "liberty" to coast fishery, 1377-8. Adams, 

 C. F., B. C. C. Ap., 105, "right" to ocean fishery and "liberty" to coast 

 fishery, 1378. Commissioners did not propose abdication of British sov- 

 ereignty, 1380. Fishery rights insisted on by American commissioners, 

 Fitzherbert to Shelburne, Dec. 4, 1782, B. C. C. Ap., 110, 1378-9, 



Negotiations, 1818, 1396-7. 



New Brunswick, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



