2444 NORTH ATLANTIC COAST FISHERIES ARBITRATION. 



Finlay, Right Honorable Sir Robert Bannatyne Continued. 

 Question 1 Continued. 



Pradier-Fodere, 9:405, servitudes, presumption in favor of servient state, 309. 



Property rights in foreign countries, 346. 



Reasonableness of regulations and concurrence of United States separable, 

 GRAY., 295; LAMMASCH, 294. 



Reasonableness of regulations to be decided by this tribunal, 298. 



Regulations: Abuse of, American argument, 336-7, 341. Aliens, imperial 

 statutes, 1786, B. C. Ap., 555, 330; 1824, B. C. Ap., 567, 333-4. British 

 position recognized five times (1) Marcy circulars, 1855-6, B. C. Ap., 

 909, 316; (2) Boutwell circulars, 1870-2, B. C. Ap., 237, 317; (3) Card- 

 well letter, 1866, B. C. Ap., 291, 317; (4) Davis, Bancroft, reported in 

 Thornton to Hill (July 10), 1873, B. C. Ap., 253, 318; GRAY, 319; (5) 

 Halifax Commission, 1877, 319. Can not be passed without concur- 

 rence of United States, GRAY, 295; LAMMASCH, 294. Consent of United 

 States thereto can not be compelled, 315-16. Delaware: Mar. 28, 1871, B. 

 C. Ap., 788,9, Sunday fishing, 335; destructive, power to make not 

 claimed by Great Britain, 301; different kinds of, U. S. A., pp. 66, 67, 

 discussed, 320-325; existed at time of 1818 treaty, 336. French shore: 

 Des Voeux to Stanhope, Nov. 24, 1886, B. C. Ap., 319, 356; lobsters, order 

 in council, 1886, U. S. C. C. Ap., 319, 356; Labrador: 1765, B. C. Ap., 690, 

 691, 327. Lower Canada: 1788, B. C. Ap., 592, Chaleurs and Gaspe Bays, 

 bait, drying, seining, ballast, offal, 331-332; 1807, B. C. Ap., 600, bait, 

 drying, seining, ballast, offal, 332; 1824, B. C. Ap., 607, 333; 1829, B. C. 

 Ap., 610, Gaspe fisheries, 333; 1836, B. C. Ap., 615, ballast, anchorage, 333. 

 Maryland: 1896, B. C. Ap., 793, nets, 335. Massachusetts: 1668, B. C. Ap., 

 770, spawning, offal, 328; 1692, B. C. Ap., 772, seining, 329; 1702, B. C. 

 Ap., 773, mackerel fishing, 329. Municipal, 343-344. Must be reasonable, 

 301. New Brunswick: 1793, B. C. Ap., 595, seining, Sunday fishing, 330; 

 1799, B. C. Ap., 597, Miramichi Bay, setting nets, seining, 330-331; 1810, 

 B. C. Ap., 604, nets, 331; 1818, B. C. Ap., 605, offal, 332; 1823, B. C. Ap., 

 607, seining, Miramichi Bay, 332; 1829, B. C. Ap., 609, seining, Miramichi 

 Bay, 332; 1834, B. C. Ap., 612, seining, Miramichi Bay, 332; 1853, B. C. Ap., 

 623, nets, gurry grounds, 332; 1854, Revised Statutes, B. C. Ap., 626, 

 gurry grounds, seining, spawning, 332-333. Newfoundland: 1611, ballast, 

 B. C. Ap., 689, 325; 1653, ballast, anchorage, B. C. Ap., 511, 325, 326; 

 1660, Star Chamber Rules, B. C. Ap., 513, ballot, anchorage, 326; 1663, 



B. C. Ap., 517, bait, 326; 1699, B. C. Ap., 525-6, bait, ballast, harbor 

 admiral, anchorage, Sunday fishing, 326-7; 1765, B. C. Ap., 690, Labrador 

 coast, 327; 1786, imperial statute, B. C. Ap., 555, seine meshes, aliens, 330; 

 1824, imperial statue, B. C. Ap., 567, ballast, nete, aliens, 333-334; 1838, 

 imperial statute, B. C. Ap., 697, ballast, 334; 1862, B. C. Ap., 702, herring, 

 salmon, seining, in-barring, seine meshes, treaty rights, 334-335; 1876, B. 



C. Ap., 707, seining, Sunday fishing, treaty rights, 335; 1877, B. C. Ap., 

 707, jigging squids, 335; 1879, B. C. Ap., 708, close season, 335. New Hamp- 

 shire: 1687, B. C. Ap., 772, mackerel fishing, seining, 329. New Jersey: 

 1826, B. C. Ap., 785, seining, 335. New Plymouth: 1668, B. C. Ap., 770, 

 offal, 329; 1670, B. C. Ap., 770, ballast, 329; 1672, B. C. Ap., 771, license, 

 329-330; 1684, B. C. Ap., 771, seining, 330. New York: 1772, B. C. Ap., 775, 

 seine meshes, 330; 1775, B. C. Ap., 776, setting nets, 330. Not excluded 

 from 1818 treaty, 336. Nova Scotia: 1665, B. C. Ap., 586, Sunday fishing, 

 license, offal, 327-328; 1770, B. C. Ap., 587, offal, 328; 1786, B. C. Ap., 591, 

 seining, Sunday fishing, 330. Prejudicial, recourse to arbitral tribunal 

 against, GRAY, 337, 338. Prejudicial to American fishermen a breach of 



