INDEX TO ORAL ARGUMENTS. 2461 



Robson, Sir William Snowden Continued. 

 Questions 3 and 4 Continued. 



Boston harbor, light dues in 1715, 1778. 



Bounty, question of in this case, 1784. 



Canso, gut of, American first protest against fees in 1806, 1780; Sabine'e re- 

 port, heavy dues in 1852, 1781. 



Cases cited: "Columbia," U. S. C. C. Ap., 632, 1790-3. 



Clearance not necessary so far as Newfoundland is concerned, 1797-8. 



Columbia, case of, U. S. C. C. Ap., 632, 1790-3. 



Customs dues, list of statutes, 0. A. Ap., 2276, 1777. See Customs Reports. 



Customs laws should be executed with least possible inconvenience to fish- 

 ing vessels, 1771. 



Customs reports: Great Britain did not require when customhouse not con- 

 venient, 1793. Necessity of, Sabine, U.S. C. Ap.,1186, Manning,^. C.Ap., 

 372, 1794. Report and entry synonymous, 1796. Statutes: Imperial: act 

 of 1661, 1787; act of 1763, 1788; act of 1767, 1788; act of 1775, 1789. New 

 Brunswick: Act of 1807, 1790. Nova Scotia: act of 1769, 1789. Prince 

 Edward Island: Act of 1775, 1789. United States: act of 1789, 1790. 



Distress, element of difference between questions 3 and 4, LAMMASCH, 1785. 



Entry and report practically synonymous, 1796. 



Fishing vessels, exemption from dues, 1783. 



Great Britain, statutes of, See Statutes cited. 



"Hovering" conducive to smuggling, 1770. 



"Hovering" laws: Imperial: 1763, B. C. Ap., 531, 1788. 



"In common:" light dues, Newfoundland statute, 1834, B. C. C. Ap., 695, 

 LAMMASCH, 1782-3; Newfoundland act of 1899, B. C. Ap., 754, 1784. 



International law writers cited: right to charge light dues: Azuni, 1773; 

 Grotius, 1771; Vattel, 1772. 



Interpretation of treaties, rights under trading or fishing treaty, 1769. 



LAMMASCH: Difference between questions 3 and 4, 1785; discrimination in 

 Newfoundland act, 1834, 1782-3. 



Light dues: Azuni, 1773. Based on security of navigation, 1773. Grotius, 

 1771. Gut of Canso in 1806, 1780. Modus vivendi of 1907, 1785. Norton 

 to Bannerman, Oct. 28, 1852, B. C. Ap., 198, light dues, 1781. Statement 

 of statutes, 0. A. Ap., 2276, 1777. Statutes: Imperial: act of 1661, 1777; 

 act of 1834, 1782; act of 1899, 1784. Massachusetts: acts of 1715, 1751, and 

 1770-1, 1778. New Brunswick: act of 1810, 1780. Newfoundland: acts of 

 1834, 1835, 1839, and 1852, 1782-4. Nova Scotia: acts of 1803, 1809, and 

 1812, 1780; acts of 1759, 1787, 1793, and 1795, 1778-9. United States: act 

 of 1804, 1780. Vattel, 1772. 



Macgregor: "Progress of America," smuggling, 1794. 



Manning's report on necessity. of customs reports, B. C. Ap., 372, 1794. 



Massachusetts, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



Miramichi Bay: light dues 1810, 1780; Sabine's report, complaint against 

 anchorage dues, 1852, 1781. 



Modus vivendi, 1907, 1785. 



New Brunswick, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



Newfoundland, conditions in 1818, 1798. 



Newfoundland, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



Nontreaty -coasts in question 4, 1768. 



Norton to Bannerman, Oct. 28, 1852, B. C. Ap., 198, light dues, 1781. 



Nova Scotia, statutes of. See Statutes cited. 



Regulations. See Customs reports, Light dues. 



Report and entry synonymous, 1796. 



