ISTDEX TO ORAL ARGUMENTS. 2467 



Robson. Sir William Snowden. 

 Question 5 Continued. 



(Jay's), B. C. Ap., 23, maritime jurisdiction, 1852, 1857; 1806, B. C. Ap., 

 24, bays, 1861; 1818, B. C. Ap., SO, "bays," 1814, 1824; 1888, B. C. Ap., 

 42 (unratified), bays, 1897. 



United States: admitted that bays must be treated differently from coasts, 

 1828; claim as to Delaware Bay, 1858; Contention as to 6-mile limit, 1821; 

 inconsistency of position re bays, 1834; interpretation of 1806 negotiations, 

 1882; renounced bays unwillingly in 1818, 1831-2; renounced nothing in 

 1818 not obtained in 1783, 1847. See Treaties cited. 



Vattel, bays, 1820-21. 



Warren's argument: Delaware Bay incident, 1851, 1894; maritime jurisdic- 

 tion, 1829, 1865; new theory as to bays, 1834, 1886-7. 

 Question 6, pp. 1905-1910. (Aug. 2, 1910.) 



Bays, British failure to maintain position of 1818, 1909. 



Bays on southern and western coasts of Newfoundland not mentioned in 

 1818, 1909. 



British failure to maintain position of 1818 regarding bays, 1909. 



British proposition in 1818, U. S. C. Ap., 312, 1908. 



Labrador and Newfoundland, treatment of in 1818, Sabine's report, 1907. 



Newfoundland, bays on southern and western coasts not mentioned in 1818, 

 1909. 



Newfoundland and Labrador, treatment of in 1818, Sabine's report, 1907. 



Negotiations in 1818, 1906. 



Treaties cited: 1783, U. S. C. Ap., 24, bays of Newfoundland and Labrador, 

 1907. 



United States proposition in 1818, U. 8. C. Ap., 310, SIS, 1906, 1908. 

 Question 7, pp. 1910-1925. (Aug. 2, 1910.) 



Bait: Newfoundland's right to refuse to sell, 1914; right to buy desired by 

 United States, 1913. 



Bond's position on bait question, U. S. C. C. Ap., 424, 1913-4. 



Commercial privileges: must be given by special agreement, 1911; treaty of 

 1818 gives none, 1911; United States shows no title to, 1922-25. 



Elder's argument on question 7, 1916, 1918, 1923-4. 



Fishing from trading vessel, 1912. 



Fishing distinguished from trading by Great Britain, 1911. 



FITZPATRICK: Fishing from trading vessel, 1912. Hovering acts, 1917. Trad- 

 ing rights conferred upon individual, not vessel, 1916. Treaty of 1818 only 

 basis of award, 1918. 



Hovering acts, FITZPATRICK, 1917. 



LAMMASCH, treaty of 1818 only basis of award, 1919. 



Municipal legislation not within scope of this tribunal, 1917. 



Newfoundland's right to refuse right to sell bait, 1914. 



Trader fishing imperils trading right, 1917. 



Trading kept separate from fishing by Great Britain, 1911. 



Trading rights conferred upon individual not vessel, FITZPATRICK, 1916. 



Trading rights imperiled by fishing, 1917. 



Trading vessel, may inhabitant of United States fish from, 1912. 



Treaties cited : 1818, B. C. Ap., SO: gives no commercial privileges, 1911 ; only 

 basis of award, FITZPATRICK, 1918, LAMMASCH, 1919. 



United States: desired right to buy bait, 1913; has burden of proving ques- 

 tion 7, 1919-21; produces no documentary evidence of rights, 1911; shows 

 no title to commercial privileges, 1922-25. 



