INDEX TO ORAL ARGUMENTS. 2507 



Turner, Honorable George Continued. 

 Question 1 Continued. 



Queen v. Keyn, L. R. (1876), 2 Ex. Div., 63, authority of text writers, 568; 

 conflict between municipal law and treaty must be settled by political 

 branch of government, 802. 



Question 1, summary of United States position on, 559-60, 865-7. 



Railways as economic servitudes, 691, 698. 



Rayneval, Jay, Franklin, conversation, Oct. 24, 1782, B. C. G. Ap. t 78, "in 

 common," 721. 



Real and personal rights, DRAGO, 845. 



Real right, essence of, LAMMASCH, 846. 



Real right without control, LAMMASCH, 847. 



Redress of United States against regulations: Appeal to British Government, 

 554. Appeal to Hague Tribunal, 556. Unreasonable regulations violate 

 treaty, 555. 



Regulated right a servitude, LAMMASCH, 626. 



Regulation of bank and coast fishery, LAMMASCH, 1775, B. C. Ap., 545, 757. 



Regulation of French right never attempted by Great Britain, 858. 



Regulations: Admission of Mr. Fish referred to others than those regulating 

 fisheries, 792. Before 1862, GRAY, 752. Dependent on balancing of 

 conveniences, 553. Duty to observe, Boutwell circular, GRAY, 808, 

 LAMMASCH, 810. Existence of, Elgin to McGregor, Aug. 8, 1906, 

 U. S. C. Ap., 986, 753, 758. First distinct issue regarding, 789. First 

 in Canada, 1892, first in Newfoundland, 1905, 759. French and American 

 rights of, similar, 863. " In common" implies submission to, 709. In dero- 

 gation of treaty right, GRAY, 546. In force in 1818, LAMMASCH, 750. In force 

 prior and subsequent to 1871 treaty, force of, DRAGO, 842. Maps showing, 

 785. Must be reasonable admitted by Great Britain, 767. Never enforced 

 under statutes of 1862 and 1868, 551. New Brunswick, 1783, B. C. Ap., 

 596, 756. Newfoundland, 1905, U. S. C. Ap., 201, 778-9, 782-3, 784. None 

 prior to 1855, law officers' statement, U. S. C. C. Ap., 251, 752. Not made 

 prior to 1862, 752. Nova Scotia, 1786, B. C. Ap., 591, 754. Objected to by 

 Fish, in 1873, 551. Of bank and coast fishery, Imperial statute, 1775, B. C. 

 Ap., 545, LAMMASCH, 757. Of 1786,5. C.Ap., 555, FITZPATRICK, 754. On 

 treaty coast, first, Newfoundland, 1862, and Canada, 1868, 757. Participa- 

 tion of United States in enforcing, FITZPATRICK, 542, 543, GRAY, 544. Police, 

 Fish's admission as to right to make, 793, 794. Policy of Newfoundland to 

 injure United States, 768. Prior and subsequent to 1871 treaty, force of, 

 LAMMASCH, 841. Redress of United States against unreasonable: appeal to 

 British Government, 554 ; appeal to Hague Tribunal, 556 ; unreasonable regu- 

 lations violate treaty, 555. Regulations in 1783-1812, LAMMASCH, 753, 755, 

 756. Subjection to, Cardwell to Lords of Admiralty, Apr. 12, 1866, B. C. Ap., 

 221,812. United States must concur in making and enforcing, 543-46. Vague 

 references to, in Halifax arbitration, 824. Violative of treaty, DRAGO, 843. 



Regulations, joint: Blaine to Lowell, Mar. 14, 1881, U. S. C. Ap., 731, 839. 

 British memorandum, May 3, 1882, U. S. C. Ap., 742-3, 839-10. France- 

 Great Britain, treaty of 1857, 848, treaty of 1885, 849, treaty of 1904, 851. 

 Frelinghuy sen's memorandum, May 9, 1882, U. S. C. Ap., 743, 840. Gran- 

 ville to Thornton, Feb. 24, 1881, U. S. C. Ap.,725, 838. GranviUe to Lowell, 

 Oct. 27, 1880, U. S. C. Ap.,713, 838. Lowell to Blaine, Mar. 12, 1881, U. S. C. 

 Ap. , 730, 839. Thornton to Granville, Mar. 14, 1881, U. S. C. Ap. , 732, 839. 



Reid, Root to, June 30, 1906, V. S. C. Ap., 980: 'In common," 713; New- 

 foundland fishery regulations, 772. 



