GENERAL ARGUMENT AGAINST 197 



extreme type of what His calls a handful of anecdotes. It is 

 reported that Sioux Indians tattoo discs on the cheekbone 

 prominences of their squaws, and it is said that similar marks 

 may be seen on some new-born children (Nature, in., 1870, 

 p. 168). And besides fictitious cases there are some puzzling 

 phenomena, which the supporters of the negative position are 

 wont to dismiss as " coincidences "which, it must be confessed, 

 is never a very satisfactory way of dealing with difficult cases. 



7. General Argument against the Transmissibility of 

 Modifications 



Most of the evidence brought forward in support of the belief 

 in the inheritance of acquired characters is terribly anecdotal ; 

 but apart from this Weismann was led to a position of entire 

 scepticism by his realisation of the continuity of the germ-plasm. 



The Apartness of the Germ-cells. If the germ-plasm or the 

 material basis of inheritance be something relatively apart from 

 the body, and from its everyday metabolism, something often 

 segregated at a very early state in development, there is a pre- 

 sumpjion against its being readily affected in a specific manner by 

 detailed exogenous changes wrought on the structure of the body. 



It seems accurate to say that the reproductive cells which 

 have the potentiality of becoming offspring never arise from 

 differentiated body-cells. Whether they are recognisable as 

 such, late or early, the germ-cells are simply those cells which 

 retain in all its integrity the complex, definite, and stable organi- 

 sation of the fertilised ovum from which the whole organism 

 develops. They have their power of reproducing creatures 

 more or less like the parents just because they are continuous, 

 through an unspecialised cell-lineage, with the fertilised ovum 

 from which the parental body arose. All the somatic cells are, 

 of course, likewise the progeny of the fertilised ovum, but in their 

 lineage there is differentiation and specialisation. We imagine 

 that in them the numerous items or potentialities in the fertilised 



