Viii PRKFACK. 



and the species has to be called Perdix perdix (L.), I can onh 

 say that I am sorry, but it cannot be helped. 



Canon Tristram's paper on the " Use and Abuse of Generic 

 Names" ("Ibis," 1895, pp. 130-133) expresses the ideas of 

 old-fashioned ornithologist on modern-day work, but my critic 

 has not shown the consistency of opinion which might have be< 

 expected from the author of such an emphatic diatribe as tl 

 which he has directed against me and my methods of worl 

 Genera are, according to Canon Tristram, entirely arbitral 

 and to be employed only for our convenience, and name 

 should not be bestowed when there is only a single species t< 

 represent them. In order to grasp my critic's full meaning, 

 consulted the published "Catalogue" of his collection, and thei 

 I found the whole of the Thrushes placed under the genus Tut 

 dus, though this is exactly the instance he quotes in his critiqut 

 in which these birds ought absolutely to be classified under the 

 heading of the two genera, Turdus and Merula. Then, in order 

 to determine what characters Canon Tristram considered to be 

 of generic value in the only instance in which he has shared 

 my crimes with me, I find that the Seychelles Scops-Owl was 

 considered by him to be worthy of a new generic name, Gym- 

 noscops, from the fact that " its ear-tufts, if any, are only rudi- 

 mentary, and its tarsi wholly unfeathered, excepting a narrow 

 line for about a quarter of an inch down the front of the tar- 

 sus, while the back of the joint is entirely bare." Slender dis- 

 tinction enough, as the describer himself seems to think, for 

 he adds : "I venture to think that these differences entitle 

 it at least to sub-generic, if not generic, rank." After this ad- 

 mission of what constitutes a generic or sub-generic difference, 

 I am surprised that Canon Tristram should have ventured to 

 stigmatise as "new fangled," "absolutely capricious," &c., 

 genera which are founded on quite as strong characters as he 

 allows to be sufficient in his own case. 



