4/8 



AMERICAN FORESTRY 



nients in regard to \vhich the friends 

 of the bill must be on their guard. 



Therefore, the only vote taken in the 

 Senate was that by which the bill was 

 made unfinished business. The division 

 on this was practically what it would 

 have been if the vote had been upon 

 the bill itself. The roll call on this was 

 as follows : 



YEAS 48 



Bacon 



Beveridge 



Bradley 



Brandegee 



Briggs 



Bulkeley 



Burkctt 



Burnham 



Burrows 



Carter 



Chamberlain 



Clapp 



Clark, Wyo. 



Crane 



Cullom 



Cummins 



Curtis 



Dcpew 



Dixon 



dn Pont 



Flkins 



Fletcher 



Flint 



Frazier 



Gallingcr 



Gamble 



Guggenheim 



Hale 



Keane 



LaFollette 



Lodge 



McEnery 



Nelson 



Oliver 



Overman 



Page 



Perkins 



Pile-: 



Purcell 



Scott 



Simmons 



Smith. S. C. 



Smoot 



Stephenson 



Sutherland 



Taylor 



Warner 



Wetmore 



NAYS -16 



Bailey 



Bankhead 



Bourne 



Bristow 



Brown 



Burton 



Crawford 



Dick 



Gore 



Heyburn 



Hughes 



Jones 



Newlands 



Paynter 



Percy 



Shivelv 



NOT VOTING 28 



A Id rich 



Borah 



Clarke, Ark. 



Clay 



Culberson 



Daniel 



Davis 



Dillingham 



Dolliver 



Foster 



Frye 



Johnston 



Lorimer 



McCumber 



Martin 



Money 



Nixon 



Owen 



Pen rose 



Rayner 



Richardson 



Root 



Smith, Md. 



Smith, Mich. 



Stone 



Taliaferro 



Tillman 



Warren 



An examination of the detailed vote 

 by states, given below, shows that 

 thirty-nine Republicans voted yes, eight 

 voted no, and thirteen were not re- 

 corded. Of the Democrats, nine voted 

 yes, eight voted no, and fifteen were 

 not recorded. An analysis of the vote 

 by sections and states is also given. 

 From this, however, in the case of the 

 Senate, little can be inferred. The 

 question seems to have been largely one 

 of personal judgment, or of personal 

 relations with other senators. 



THE SENATE VOTE IN DETAIL 



ALABAMA 



John i//. Batikhcad, no. 



/. r. Johnston, did not vote. 



ARKANSAS 



James P. Clarke, did not vote. 

 Jeff Dan's, did not vote. 



CALIFORNIA 



George C. Perkins, yes. 

 Frank P. Flint, yes. 



COLORADO 



Simon Guggenheim, yes. 

 Charles J. Hughes, Jr., no. 



CONNECTICUT 



Morgan G. Bulkeley, yes. 

 Frank B. Brandegee, yes. 



DELAWARE 



Henry A. du Pont, yes. 



Harry A. Richardson, did not vote. 



FLORIDA 



/. P. Taliaferro, did not vote. 

 Duncan U. Fletcher, yes. 



GEORGIA 



.higitstits O. Bacon, yes. 

 Alexander S. Clay, did not vote. 



IDAHO 



W. B. Heyburn, no. 



William E. Borah, did not vote. 



ILLINOIS 



Shelby M. Cullom, yes. 

 William Lorimer, did not vote. 



INDIANA 



Albert J. Beveridge, yes. 

 Benjamin F. Shivcly, no. 



