THE BEE-KEEPERS' REVIEW 151 



]\Ir. Cavanagh, delegate, of Chicago-Xorthwestern Branch, pre- 

 sented some strong arguments as to why in his opinion the REViiiw 

 should not have been purchased, and asked for further information. 



]\Ir. J. J. Anderson, delegate, of Idaho Hone}- I'roducers' Asso- 

 ciation, entered a vigorous defense of the directors regarding the 

 purchase of the Review. Dr. E. F. Phillips, Dr. H. A. Surface, and 

 others, entered into the discussion, some favoring and others ques- 

 tioning the action of the directors in purchasing the Bee-Keepers' 

 Rexiew. The discussion was not entered into at length at this time 

 as it would come up again when the proposed changes in the con- 

 stitution were taken up, so the Treasurer's report was called for. 

 This was read by Director E. D. Townsend, and is as follows: 



INCOME. 

 1912 



Jan. 1 From former N. B. K. A $ 28.09 



Feb. 2 From E. B. Tvrrell 57.00 



2 From E. B. Tyrrell 15.00 



15 From E. B. Tyrrell 14.50 



Mar. 7 From E. B. Tyrrell 93.00 



17 From E. B. Tyrrell 15.00 



28 From E. B. Tyrrell 14.00 



Apr. 1 From E. B. Tyrrell 5.00 



16 From E. B. Tyrrell 31.00 



May 17 From E. B. Tyrrell 64.15 



24 F"rom E. B. Tyrrell 65.27 



27 From E. B. Tyrrell 50.30 



June 4 From E. B. Tyrrell 58.50 



12 From E. B. Tyrrell 57.54 



July 8 From E. B. Tyrrell 206.62 



27 From E. B. Tyrrell 170.27 



.Aug. 5 From E. B. Tyrrell 127.79 



20 I-^rom E. B. Tyrrell 188.39 



Sept. 9 From T. B. Tyrrell 120.69 



" 16 From E. B. Tyrrell 88.42 



Oct. 4 From E. B. Tyrrell 198.35 



21 From E. B. Tyrrell 130.77 



Nov. 7 From E. B. Tyrrell 156.11 



22 From E. B. Tyrrell 179.40 



Dec. 6 From E. B. Tyrrell 117.40 



21 From E. B. Tyrrell 159.13 



" 30 From E. B. Tyrrell 229.66 



1913 



Jan. 7 From E. B. Tyrrell 173.08 



13 From E. B. Tyrrell 196.95 



25 From E. B. Tyrrell 220.61 



$3,231.99 



DISBURSEMENTS. 



Order 



No. 



1 Feb. 6 GfcL,. Drake & Co $53 51 



2 " 6 E. B. Tvrrell 6 95 



3 Mar. 11 E. B. Tyrrell 21.62 



4 " 11 Geo. Drake & Co 19 17 



5 " 20 Chas. F. May Co 5.00 



