MORE AS TO THE BARNACLE AND GOOSE 141 



in fact, any kind of goose was so. He also put aside 

 the evidence of Father Damien (earlier than the Irish 

 story of Giraldus) referring the goose-tree to an island 

 in the Indies, and the report cited in the Oriental 

 book the " Zohar." However plausible Max Muller's 

 theory may have appeared, it absolutely crumbles and 

 disappears in the presence of the Mykenaean pictures of 

 "barnaculized" geese, and trees budding birds two 

 thousand years older than the Irish record, and nearly 

 three thousand years earlier than the essay of the charm- 

 ing and persuasive professor. 



