356 (josMOS. 



where large sections are separated into a few but large divi- 

 sions ; so it also appears to me, that in the determination of 

 races a preference should be given to the establishment of 

 small families of nations. Whether we adopt the old classi- 

 fication of my master, Blumenbach, and a.dmit Jive races (the 

 Caucasian, Mongolian, American, Ethiopian, and Malayan), 

 or that of Prichard, into seve7i races* (the Iranian, Turanian, 

 American, Hottentots and Bushmen, Negroes, Papuas, and 

 Alfourous), we fail to recognize any typical sharpness of def- 

 inition, ^or any general or well-established principle in the di- 

 vision of these groups. The extremes of form and color are 

 certainly separated, but without regard to the races, which 

 can not be included in any of these classes, and which have 

 been alternately termed Scythian and Allophyllic. Iranian is 

 certainl}* a less objectionable term for the European nations 

 than Caucasian ; but it may be maintained generally that 

 geographical denominations are very vague when used to ex- 

 press the points of departure of races, more especially where 

 the country which has given its name to the race, as, for in- 

 stance, Turau (Mawerannahr), has been inhabited at differ- 

 ent periods! by Indo-Germanic and Finnish, and not by Mon- 

 golian tribes. 



* Prichard, op. cit., vol. i., p. 247. 



t The late arrival of tlie Turkish and Mongolian tribes on the Oxua 

 and on the Kirghis Steppes is opposed to the hypothesis of Niebuhr, 

 accordhig to which the Scythians of Herodotus and Hippocrates were 

 Mongolians. It seems far more probable that the Scythians (Scoloti) 

 should be referred to the Indo-Germanic Massage t<e (Alani). The 

 Mongolian, true Tartars (the latter term was afterward falsely given to 

 purely Turkish tribes in Russia and Sibei'ia), were settled, at that pe- 

 riod, far in the eastern part of Asia. See my Asie Centrale, t. i., p. 239, 

 400 ; Examen Critique de VHistoire de la Giogr., th. ii., p. 320. A dis- 

 tinguished philologist, Professor Buschmann, calls attention to the cir- 

 cumstance that the poet Firdousi, in his half-mythical prefatory remarks 

 in \\ie Schahnameh, mentions "a fortress of the Alani'' on the sea-shore, 

 in which Selm took refuge, this prince being the eldest son of the 

 King Feriduu, who in all probability lived two hundred years before 

 Cyrus. The Kirghis of the Scythian steppe were originally a E'innish 

 tribe ; their three hordes probably constitute in the present day the 

 most numerous nomadic nation, and their tribe dwelt, in the sixteenth 

 century, in the same steppe in which I have myself seen them. The 

 Byzantine Menander (p. 380-382, ed. Nieb.) expressly states that the 

 Chacan of the Turks (Thu-Khiu), in 5G9, made a present of a Kirghis 

 slave to Zemarchus, the embassador of Justinian II. ; he terms her a 

 X^PXk ) tiiid. we find in Abulgasi {Historia MongoJorum el Tataroruni) 

 that the Kirghis are called Kirkiz. Similarity of manners, where the 

 nature of the country determines the i)rincipal characteristics, is a very 

 uncertain evidence of identity of race. The life of the steppes pro- 

 duces among the Turks (Ti Tukiu), the Baschkirs (Fins), the Kirghis, 



