546 THE MAGAZINE OF HORTICULTURE 



where it was as large as the Spitzenberg. Others spoke 

 highly of its quality, but thought it too small. C. M. Hovey 

 thought it remarkably beautiful and fine. It was generally 

 considered among the best, and recommended for general 

 cultivation. 



White Seek-no-Further. — Considered by some identical 

 with the Ortley. On account of the growth of the tree, which 

 was poor, it was removed from the list heretofore adopted. 



Wells and Dominie were decided to be identical. 



Willow Twig, Rawle's Janet, Pryor's Red, Rome 

 Beauty, Liberty, White Pippin and Cooper, were discussed 

 with the specimens before the meeting. 



Winter Sweet Paradise was considered by Mr. Bateham 

 the best winter sweet apple, better than Ladies' Sweeting ; 

 resembles in its growth Northern Spy. Recommended as 

 promising well. 



Smith's Cider. — One of the most profitable apples in Ohio, 

 and extensively cultivated around Cincinnati. It is a fine 

 table fruit. Recommended as promising well. 



Fallawater. Dr. Brinckle and Mr. Waring thought it a 

 fine apple. It is much cultivated in Pennsylvania and the 

 West. Recommended as promising well. 



Broadwell was recommended as promising well. 



The meeting then adjourned to Friday, Sept. 26tli. 



PEACHES. 



Early Crawford and Old Mixon Cling were recommend- 

 ed for general cultivation. 



SUSQ,UEHANNA, HiLL's ChILI, GoRGAS, MaDELEINE DE 



CouRSON, and Hative de Neigs, were recommended as 

 promising well. 



Early Tillotson was generally considered as a poor bear- 

 er, very subject to mildew. 



CHERRIES FOR GENERAL CULTIVATION. 



Doavnton was removed from the old list. Considered a 

 shy bearer and not of remarkable quality. 



Napoleon Bigarreau was recommended for special culti- 



