10 INFLUENCE OF PARENTAL ALCOHOLISM 



The true criticism for Professor Marshall, the only line 

 of argument valid for Mr. Keynes, was to analyse care- 

 fully themselves the trades followed by the drinking and 

 temperate sections, and show that they supported the 

 view that these sections were mentally or physically 

 differentiated. As they did not attempt to do this, it 

 seemed worth while publishing such an analysis of the 

 trades of the population dealt with. It runs as follows : 



Class A. — Papercutters (24s. ; S i, D i), cabmen (i8s. 5^. ; 

 S I, D 10), goldbeaters (21s. 6d. ; S 2, D i), stablemen 

 (21S. 2d. ; S I, D 5), millworkers (19s. ; S 2, D 0), porters 

 (20S. 6d. ; S 9, D 8), warehouse (245. 4^. ; S 8, D 2), malt- 

 men (23s. ; S 3, D 5), chimney-sweeps (17s. 4^. ; S o, D 7), 

 carters (22s. 2d. ; S 12, D 23), barman (23s. 8^. ; S i, D o), 

 brassfounders (21s. 6d. ; S 2, D 4), shoemakers (22s. lod. ; 

 S II, D 9), scavengers (22s. 10^. ; S 2, D 2), stonecutters 

 (23s. ; S I, D i), cellarmen (24s. 2d. ; S i, D 2), french- 

 polisher (13s. 6d. ; S i, D o), wagon examiner (2ps. ; 

 S I, D o), surfacemen (i8s. 6d. ; S 4, D o), gardeners 

 20S. 6d. ; S 2, D 0), platelayers (i8s. ; S o, D 2), hammer- 

 men (20S. ; S 2, D i), factory workers (12s. ; S i, D 3), 

 billposter (i8s. ; S i, D o), hawkers, general labourers, and 

 odd-jobbers (14s. to 23s. ; S 71, D 85). 



Class B. — Sadlers (25s. ; S o, D 3), turnroom (25s. ; S i, 

 D 0), shop hands (25s. ; S 4, D 3), typecasters (26s. ; S 4, 

 D 5), clerks (27s. ; S 2, D i), ironmoulders (28s. 5^. ; S 3, 

 D 5), coachbuilders (28s. ; S 3, D i), wellsinker (30s. ; S i, 

 D 0), tailors (27s. ; S 4, D 15), coopers (28s. 6d. ; S 8, D 4), 

 linesmen (26s. ; S o, D 2), timekeeper (30s. ; S i, D o), 

 jewellers (28s. ; S 2, D 0), butchers (30s. ; S 2, D i), 

 painters (25s. 6d. ; S 14, D 23), pipelayer (27s. 8d. ; S o, 

 D i), sailors (30s. ; S 3, D i), bakers (26s. 2d.; S 11, 

 D 10), bottler (27s. 3^. ; S i, D 0), railway porters (28s. : 



