xxxv] MESMERISM TO SPIRITUALISM 285 



"Your book will set many rational persons suspecting 

 they ought to inquire. 



■ Yours faithfully, 



"A. de Morgan." 



This seems to me to exhibit the scientific frame of mind, 

 as manifested by Tyndall, Lewes, and W. B. Carpenter, with 

 great perspicuity. 



I had some correspondence at this time with William 

 Howitt, and he and Mrs. Howitt came one evening for a 

 stance with Miss Nichol, and were much pleased with the 

 curious musical and other phenomena ; and I also made 

 the acquaintance of Mr. and Mrs. S. C. Hall, and visited 

 them to attend a stance with Home, which, although all 

 present were friends and spiritualists, turned out a failure, 

 owing to the circle being broken by Mr. Hall being called 

 out on urgent business. 



But perhaps the most interesting response to a copy of 

 my pamphlet was that from Robert Chambers, which I here 

 give— 



"St. Andrews, February io, 1867. 



"Dear Sir, 



" I have received your letter of the 6th inst, and 

 your little volume. It gratifies me much to receive a friendly 

 communication from the Mr. Wallace of my friend Darwin's 

 ' Origin of Species,' and my gratification is greatly heightened 

 on finding that he is one of the few men of science who 

 admit the verity of the phenomena of spiritualism. I have 

 for many years known that these phenomena are real, as 

 distinguished from impostures ; and it is not of yesterday 

 that I concluded they were calculated to explain much that 

 has been doubtful in the past, and when fully accepted, 

 revolutionize the whole frame of human opinion on many 

 important matters. 



****** 



"How provoking it has often appeared to me that it 



