204 [AssEMBL-y 



PFJins •vviiiai IT WAS proposkd to nrjECT. 



Jlmlrcsia. — Objcctcil to by Mr. Elliott, of Cleveland, Ohio, and 

 retained. 



Jlmand^ Dcuhle. — Objected to by Mr. Manice, of Long Island, 

 N. Y. 



Beurr&,d'Elbec. — Objected to by Mr. Hovey, of Boston, Mas 



Boucquia. — Objected to by Mr. IIovey, of Boston, Mass. 



Bcrgamctte Parthmay. — Objected to by Mr. Maktell of New- 

 York Island. 



Cmnlcrland. — Objected to by Mr. Manice, of Long Island. He 

 considered it a good baking pear. 



Colmar a'Ete. — Objected to by Mr. Hovey, of Mass., and Mr. 

 Mantell, of New-York. 



Infant Prodige. — Objected to by Mr. S. B. Parsons, of Flushing, 

 I^ew-York. 



Fcndante (PEte. — Objected to by Mr. Gabriel, of New-Haven, 

 Conn. With him it was a superior pear on quince stock. 



Gilogil. — Objected to by Mr. Reid, of Elizabethtown, N. J. 

 "With him it was a good pear on quince. Also, by Mr. Maktell, of N. 

 Y. It vras good with him on quince. 



Zoc/g-e.— Objected to by Dr. Brinckl^, of Philadelphia, Penn.; 

 and Mr. Hancocic, of Burlington, N. J. 



Vallee Franche. — Objected to by Mr. Hovey, of Boston, Mass. 



Windsor. — Objected to by Mr. McIntosh, of Cleveland, Ohio ; 

 Mr. Reid, of Elizabethtown, N. J. ] Mr. Hovey, of Boston, Mass. ; 

 and Mr. Saul, of Newburgh, N. Y. 



Rousselct de Stuttgardt. — Objected to by Mr. Barry, of Rochester, 

 N. Y. 



Belle de Bruxelles. — Objected to by Mr. Barry, of Rochester, 

 with him it v.'as a fine, beautiful fruit. Also by Mr. Hovey, of Bos- 

 ton, who h.ad found it a very handcome and showy pear, and had 

 often been offered a York shilling apiece for the fruit by visitors, who 

 saw it growing on the tree at his establishment. Judging it by 

 strictly Pomological rules, he thought it about a third rate fruit. 

 Mr. Walxer, of Boston, said the fruit was handsome, indeed, but 

 utterly worthless. It was, perhap?, the most deceptive variety in the 

 whole catalogue. He apprehended his friend Hovey did not sell it 



