No. IDO]; £21 



APPr.ES WHICH IT WAS PRolcSED TO RFJECT . 



Cacashca. — Objected to by Col. IJodge, of Buflfalo, N. Y. It was 

 only a second quality of fruit, but he was not prepared to reject It 

 altogether. Also by Mr. Barry of Rochester, N. Y. It was large 

 and productive, very coarse, but still had some good qualities. 



Blenheim Pippin. — Objected toby Mr. Hovey, of Boston, Mass. 



American Pippin or Grindstone. — 'Objected to by Mr. Hayes, of 

 Newark, N. J. 



Scarlet Pearmain. — Objected to by Col. Hodge of Buffalo, N. Y., 

 and Mr. Elliott, of Cleveland, Ohio. 



PEARS WHICH IT WAS PROPOSED TO REJECT. 



Sugar Top. — Objected to by Mr. McIntosh, of Cleveland, Ohio. 



Sugar of Hoyerswerda. — Objected to by Mr. Makice, of Long- 

 Island, N. Y. 



Princess of Orange. — Objected to by Col. Hodge of Buffalo, N.Y. 



Hessel. — Objected to by Mr. Saul, of Newburgh, N, Y., and Mr. 

 McIntosh, of Cleveland, Ohio. 



Hericort. — Objected to by Messrs. Hayes, of Newark, N. Jersey, 

 Manice, of Long Island, N. Y., Hoyey, of Boston, Mass., and Saul, 

 of Newburgh, N. Y. 



This completed the list of fruits which the committee proposed to 

 submit for rejection. Thereupon 



Mr. Hakcock proposed to add to the list of rejected pears, the 

 Dumorlicr and the Passans de Portugal. Both were objected to— 

 the former by Mr. Hovey, of Boston, and the latter by Messrs. Ho- 

 vey and Walker of Boston. 



Mr. Miller proposed to add Prince''s St. Germain, Objected to 

 by Messrs. McIntosh, of Cleveland, Ohio ; Moxson, of New Haven, 

 and Terry, of Hartford, Conn.; Manice, of Long Island, N. Y,; 

 Hovey, of Boston, Mass., and Little, of Bangor, Maine. 



Mr. Little then moved that the meeting proceed further to con- 

 sider the list recommended by the committee as worthy of general 

 cultivation, and the motion was sustained. 



fruits worthy or general cultivation. 

 Mr. Downing raid the committee intended to propose but one 

 Cherry, and that was the Belle Magnifquc. Mr. Hovey said it had 

 been known in Massachusetts from ten to twenty years ; Mr. El- 



