1 DR. MACIOLEK: Okay, well, there is only that one table pertaining 



2 to biology about halfway down page 14, where we got into that impact. 



3 Fred, you were saying that you thought this material just did not 



4 belong. 



5 DR. GRASSLE: I think it should just be tightened up a lot, and 



6 maybe we could quickly go through it. 



7 Maybe this whole business about the area of the 1 percent--say 



8 that one approach to looking at this is to take an arbitrary 1 percent 



9 and consider the surface area involved and what the source is and do 



10 some calculations, and have that as an approach to the problem. 



11 Then it seems to me that life stages and sensitivity needs a 



12 separate section. We had some more of that in the afternoon. 



13 It really could be tightened up into a couple of pages. 



14 I think that, John, maybe you could have a go at the 1 percent and 



15 the surface area-- 



16 DR. TEAL: I would like to leave that out. 



17 DR. GRASSLE: No, but instead of having the discussion verbatim, 



18 let's say an approach to thinking about the problem is to calculate--you 



19 know, the sort of calculation Brad was going through of the surface 



20 area, and Mike and so on--that approach to things--the calculation, and 



21 then you could put in--I mean, I am happy to leave the 1 percent thing 



22 out, but that approach to thinking about the problem should be apparent. 



23 So can you write that paragraph? 



24 DR. TEAL: I have to leave in 45 minutes so I am just going to 



25 write it. 



26 DR. GRASSLE: Write that paragraph? 



27 (Simultaneous discussion.) 



28 DR. MACIOLEK: Does that take us to the end of this first section, 



29 then? 



30 DR. GRASSLE: I will have a go at the life stages and sensitivity 



31 one. 



32 How about impacts on sessile organisms? I think that can go under 



33 John's section, whatever its use was in there, and I think that--I do 



34 not think that the measure quantifying biological impact says anything 



371 



