MATTER RELATING TO OWNERSHIP OF CERTAIN SEALING 

 VESSELS SEIZED BY THE UNITED STATES. 



extracts from notes made at the trial of the case of 

 warren vs. boscowitz and cooper. 



in the supreme court of british columbia. 



Between Hannah Warren, plaintiff, and Joseph Boscowitz 

 and T. H. Cooper, defendant. 



I, Harvey Combe, deputy registrar of the supreme court of British 

 Columbia, do hereby certify that the paper writing hereuuto annexed 

 and marked with the letter A, and containing five pages, each respec- 

 tively bearing my signature, is a true and correct copy of extracts made 

 from the transcript of the official shorthand notes taken at the trial in 

 the above suit. 



Witness my hand and seal of the said supreme court of British Co- 

 lumbia this 27th day of September, A. D. 1889. 



[seal.] Harvey Combe, 



Deputy Registrar. 

 A. 



IN THE SUFREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA. 



(Before chief justice and special jury.) 



June 4th, 18S9. 



Hannah Warren vs. Joseph Boscowitz and T. H. Cooper. 

 Mr. W. J. Taylor for the claimant, Hannah Warren ; Mr. Theodore 

 Davie, Q. C, for the deft., Boscowitz. 



(FIRST DAY.) 



George E. Munro, under cross examination by Mr. T. Davie: 

 85(>. Q. Come over and shew the jury exactly what this is made up 

 of. Bemember that Mrs. Warren had nothing to do with the sealers; 

 yet she takes credit for this $504.40. — A. Mr. Boscowitz should have 

 paid for it. I charged it up to the Grace and gave Mr. Boscowitz credit 

 for it. These boats are supposed to be owned by Mrs. Hannah War- 

 ren. That is one of the items — there is the Dolphin's chronometer. 

 That was charged in the general books which they had no business to 

 put in here. It was charged here, but should have been charged in 

 Mr. Boscowitz' sealing books. Afterwards, to keep a correct account 

 with the sealing schooners, I afterwards brought it into these books. 



301 



