July 29, 1910] 



SCIENCE 



133 



aging schools to teach the "laws of falling bodies " 

 in their simplest form and so [go on] to the 

 formula K. E. = mv- -=- 2g, but with no recogni- 

 tion, in admission requirements or examinations, 

 of " absolute " units of force or energj' or of the 

 formula f = m X a. 



iName 



Position 



TABULATION OF REPLIES^ TO CIRCULARS 



In the following tabulation the sign — 

 indicates approval of the original propo- 

 sition in question without the suggestion 

 which is attached to it in the postal-card 



circulars. The sign + indicates approval 

 of the proposition in question with the 

 suggestion which is attached to it in the 

 same circulars. A numeral put with 

 either of these signs refers to a foot-note in 

 which some comment by the individual 

 replying is given or indicated. Absence of 

 any sign indicates lack of approval of the 

 proposition in question. 



In the class of College Teachers are in- 

 cluded a number of men who are no longer 

 teaching, being now members of govern- 

 ment bureaus. 



Approvals by College Teachers 



Propositions 



C. A. Butman, Clark Coll., Worcester, Mass 



W. G. Cady, Wesleyan TJniv 



L. L. Campbell, Simmons Coll., Boston 



J. G. Coffin, C C. N. Y., Kew York City... 



Henry Crew, Northwestern Univ 



Grace C. Davis, Wellesley Coll 



H. N. Davis, Harvard Univ 



H. G. Dorsev, Cornell Univ 



C. K. Edmunds, Canton Christian Coll , 



C. F. Emerson, Dartmouth Coll 



"W. G. Fisher, Cornell Univ 



W. S. Franklin, Lehigh Univ 



H. G. Gale, Univ. of Chicago 



C. M. Gordon, Lafayette Coll 



K. E. Guthe, Univ. of Michigan 



E. A. Harrington, Williams Coll 



J. E. Hayford, Northwestern Univ 



W. L. Hooper, Tufts Coll 



J. C. Hubbard, Clark Coll 



G. F. Hull, Dartmouth Coll 



W. J. Humphreys, U. S. Weather Bureau... 

 J. E. Kershner, Franklin & Marshall Coll... 



Elizabeth B. Laird, Mt. Holyoke Coll 



W. F. Magie, Princeton Univ .' 



W. E. McElfresh, Williams Coll 



P. W. McNair, Mich. Coll. of Mines 



C. E. Mann, Univ. of Chicago 



A. A. Michelson, Univ. of Chicago 



W. A. Mitchell, Soochow Univ., China 



C. C. Murdock, Cornell Univ 



A. de F. Palmer, Brown Univ 



R. A. Porter, Syracuse Univ 



E. B. Rosa, Bureau of Stand 



F. A. Saunders, Syracuse Univ 



F. Slate, Univ. of California 



M. H. Walbridge, Rand. Ma. Coll 



F. A. Waterman, Smith Coll 



A. G. Webster, Clark Univ 



W. R. Whitehouse, Bates Coll 



J. F. Woodhull, Teachers Coll., New York. 



+ I - 



+ 



+? 



+ 



+ 



+ 



+ 



-f 



+ 



+ 



+ 



+ 



+ 



+ 



+ 

 + 



-I- 



+ 

 + 



+ 



+ 



+ 



^ I have studied these replies with care and hope, without being sure, that no errors will be found 

 in the details of the tabulation. 



