F 



Vol. Ill, No, 9.] Nyaya-jpravesa. 613 



[N.S.] 



Sound is not a product of effort, 

 Because it is non-etemal. 



(viii) When thiugs denoted by the roason consist oP some 



things heterogeneous from and all things homogene- 



ous with things denoted by the predicate, 3^*3^^^' 



'^^•^'g^^^'^s^'^^S'^'f^'y^ 



q-fiiq-q 



e.q. 



Sound is a product of effort, 

 Because it is non-eternal. 



(ix) When things denoted by the reason consist of some tilings 



homogeneous with aiidsome things heterogeneous from 



things denoted by the piedicate, ^'J^'^^'g^^P 



^q|-q]-53q-q-uqr^'q^ e.g.- 



Sound is eternal, 

 Because it is incorporeal. 



(x) When the contradiction (between the reasons advanced 



by two parties respectivrly) is unenoneous, Q^Onttl'^'flJ* 



o 1 - i 1 / Sound is eternal, 



bound IS non-cternai, i 



r» M . J i. \ Because it is always 



Because it is a product^ J ludible 



(c) The Inconsistent ( fV^^j ^^'^'^) are the fallacies 



which occur. 



(xi) When the reason is inconsistent with the predicate itself, 



Sound is eternal, 

 Because it is a product. 



: xii) When the reason is inconsistent with the implied predi- 





The eye, etc., are serviceable to some being, 

 Because tlioy are compounds. 



