^fff 



ANALYSIS OF THE WHEEL. 



1 



Sound is eternal, 



Because it is knowable (S is R). 



(n) The knowablea are all eternals ae 

 etlier (R iH all P), that is, all eternals are 

 knowablca as ethor. 



(h) The knowahles are all tion-etornals, as 

 a pot fR 18 all non.Pj, that is, allnon-oter- 



nala are knowables as a pot 



1. SIsR 



2. RisuU 



3. Biflull 



P 



uon-P 



» ■ • 



right 



right 

 w ro n g 



reasoning 

 is un- 

 sound. 



4 



Sound is eternal, 



Because it is adventitious (S is R)» 



(fl) The adventitious arc 



ether (R ia no P), that is, 



not advcntitioas as ether. 



not eternal as 

 the eternals are 



(b) The non-oternals are all adventitious 

 (R is all nouP^, that is, the adventitious are 

 nou-eternals as a pot. 



1. SisR 



2. B ia no P 



8. R ia all uon-P ... 



I h 



<tt< 



right 



wrong 



wrong 



i reasoning 

 is im- 

 sound. 



2 



Sound is non-eternal, 



Because it is advpntitious (S is R). 



(a) The adv<*ntit5ons are all non 

 as a pot iR in all Pi, that is, all non 



are adventitious, as a pot. 



eternals 

 eternals 



(b) No non-eternals are adventitious as 

 ether, that ia, non-adventitions are no non- 

 eternals as ether (R is no nou-Pj. 



1. 

 2. 



3. 



S IB R 

 R is all.P 



R is no non-P ... 



* • * 



* • • 



rights reasoning 

 right > is 



right) SOUDd. 



5 



Sound is non-eternal, 

 Because it is aadible,(S is R), 



fa) The audibles are not non-eternals as 

 pot (R is no Pi, that is, the non-eternals 

 are not audiblea as a pot, 



(h) No non-non-ptf»rnal (that ia, etf^rnal), 

 ifi au'Uhlo as pther, that is, no audible is non- 

 nou-eternul as ether (R is no non-P). 



a 



I. 



2. 



8. 



SisR 



R is no P 



R is no non-P ... 



■ * - 



• 4 t 



right 

 wrong 



riglit 



reasoning 

 is un- 

 sound. 



3 



Sound is a product of effort, 

 Becanse it ia non-eternal (S is R), 



(a) The non-etprnals are all products-of- 

 effort as a pot (R is all P), that is, all pro- 

 dncts-of-fffort are non -eternals as a p«>t. 



(b) S<»nie non-prodiiCt-of.ffforfc is non- 

 eternal «a lightning, tliat is, the not»-eternal 



is sarne-non-produot-of-efEort as lightning 

 (R is some non-P). 



(c) Some non- prod not-of -effort is not 

 non-eternal as ether, that ia, the non-eternal 



is notpome-non-prodnct-of-effort as ether 

 (R is not some non-Pj, 



1. S is R ... riffht ] 



2. R is all-P ... right I reasoning 

 8. B is some non-P wroug Y is nn- 



and R is nob ' | sound., 



some non-P. J 



6 



Sound is eternal, 



Because it is a product of effort (S is R). 



(a ' The products of effort are not eternals 

 (R is no I* i, that is, the eternals are not pro- 

 ducts of effort, ns etiier. 



(h) The products of effort are some nnn- 

 eiemalfl, as a pot (R is some non-P), that is, 

 some non-eternals are products of effort as 

 a pot. 



(c) The products of effort are not some 



not some 

 are not 



non-eternals, as lightning (R is 

 noM-P), that is, some non-eternals 

 products of effort as lightning 

 1. SisR 



2. 

 3. 



B is no P 



K is some non-P 

 R is not 

 non-P, 



• •• 



■ > I 



some 



right 

 wrong 



wrong 



reason- 



^ ing 

 is un- 

 sound. 



< 



o 



bo 



o 



6^ 



C6 



I 





CO 



