ANALYSIS OF THE AVHEEL 



ont 1717 led. 



7 



Sotind is a non-protluct of ofCorh, 



Beo«n«e it is non-eternal (S is R). 



{a) The non-eternals are some non-pro- 

 ducts of effort as lightning (R is some P), 

 that isj aoTxie non-products of effort are non- 

 eternals as lightning. 



(h) The non-oternals are not some non- 

 products of effort, as liglitning (R is not 

 Bome-P), that is, some non-products of effort 

 ar6 not non-eternals an ether. 



(c) The non-eternals are all non-products 

 of effort as a pot (R is all non-P). 



S ia R -. right 



R ia some P 

 R is not somo-P 

 R ia all non-P 



•" j right 



1 • ■ 



wrong 



reason- 

 ing 



is un- 

 sound. 



8 



Sound is non-eternal, ,„ ry\ 



Because it ia n prodnct of effort (S is 11). 



(a) The products of effort are some non- 

 eternals, that is, some non-eternala are pro- 

 ducts of effort as n pot (R is some P). 



{b) The products of effort are not some 

 non-eternals as lightning (R is not some 

 P), that is, some non-eternals are not pro- 

 ducts of effort as lightning. 



(c) The non-non-ett^rnals are not products 

 of effort, as ether, that is, the products of 

 effort are no non-non-eternals as ether 



(R is no non-P). 

 1. S is R 



•«■ 



right '^ 



re son- 



( R is some-P .. j ^. y^^ ( j^g ^g 

 ^" I R is not some-P ... ) ^ V an.TnH 



3. R is no non-P 



■ • • 



right 







Sound is eternal, 

 Because it is corporeal (S is R) ? 

 (a) The corporeals are some eternals as 

 ntoms (R is some P), that is, some eternals 



are corporeals ns atoms. 



{b) The corporeals are not some eternals, 



as ether (R* is not some P), that is, some 

 eternals are hot corporeals as ether. 



(cj The corporeals are some non-eternals 

 as a pot (R is some non-P). 



{d) The corporeals are not some nou- 

 eternals as an action (R is not some non-P). 



1. SisR? ... wrong "^ 



■••] right l''^^^^"- 

 R is some non-P ... ^ 



2. 



{R is some P 

 R is not some P 



3. 



R is not 

 non-P. 



some 



wrong 



ing 

 is un- 

 sound. 



J 



CO 



^ 



g 



a 



.o 



CO 



OS 



o 



<X) 



to 



'iQ 

 » 



o 



CD 



o 



CD 



CD 



