1918.] The Tattva-cintamant. 305 
effect. Why does he then entertain doubt? It is 
incompatible with his own activity. There is no 
doubt that smoke as an effect cannot be produced 
without a cause. Smoke is in fact a product of 
fire without which it cannot abide. 
MATA: | 
Comprehensiveness of Invariable Concomitance. 
_ Comprehensiveness (anugama) is the nature which exhibits 
in one form all the various kinds of invariable concomitance 
previously defined. The invariable concomitance involving 
reciprocal non-existence is a comprehensive one, and is on 
account of shortness to be accepted as the cause of inference. 
Of the five provisional definitions of invariable concomitance 
the third and the fifth, and of those of the invariable concomi- 
tance of a special form, the second and the third involve reci- 
procal non-existence. The conclusive definition of invariable 
concomitance may also be so modified as to involve reciprocal 
non-existence. Of these the third definition of the invariable 
concomitance of a special form is by far very short. 
SlAqlTqaaa | 
Intercourse whose Character is General. 
We observed that there is invariable concomitance of smoke 
of a kitchen with fire of the same, and similarly there is invari- 
able concomitance of smoke of a sacrificial ground with fire of 
the same. Though we thus observe that there is invariable 
that in perceiving a particular smoke by means of our eye there 
urse of uni ‘hi ki 
