PRINCIPAL GARDENERS—WILLIAM MCNAB. 315 
We obtain some idea of the general respect which William 
McNab inspired and of the esteem in which he was held from 
the demonstration in his honour which took place in 1844. 
The following circular shows its initiation :— 
M‘NAB TESTIMONIAL. 
5 
o 
i=) 
5 . 
cr 
1) 
ij 
is) 
n 
Ck 
o 
5 
ee 
i 
m 
ao 
Py 
o 
= 
2) 
ae 
ie) 
je 
° 
beg | 
w 
2) 
et 
pe) 
pe 
“<j 
fe) 
=] 
joe 
° 
be | 
=. 
Q 
co 
2 
ae) 
me 
n 
removal of trees, shrubs, and plants, to their new jation—som 
of them of large size, and probably 100 years old. During his whole 
career, Mr M‘Naz has pursued a steady and trusive course of 
wn. 
It was therefore proposed, and cordially responded to, that a 
Fund should be raised, by general subscription, with the view of 
Rosa Borrerii — —roadside near Hale. 
2 Vtllosa? —between Hale and Collington. : 
»» tvoluta | —Collington Churchyard. 
»» villosa? —-by side of mill-lead near Coltbridge. 
i wo } —Caroline Park and Cramond. 
and then collected on 19th October 1845 :— 
_ Rosa new sp. —roadside near Dryden Burying-ground. 
% Caesta? —south end of coal-pit near Cockpen Church. 
» @rvensis | —from Tynningham woods (received from Mr. Sabine). 
