236 
JOURNAL OF HORTICULTURE AND COTTAGE GARDENER. 
{ September 26, 1878. 
bracketed together. Then the second column gives the name 
of the Rose, followed by the letters indicating the character of 
the Rose. Then follow the date of its introduction and the 
raiser’s name. Some blanks may still be found here, but the 
columns are gradually becoming complete. Then follow the 
amateur votes, A B C representing respectively the votes given 
in first and second twelves and the next twenty-four. Then 
the total of amateur votes, Then the votes of nurserymen. 
The total and the grand total. 
Alongside of this general election of forty-eight varieties 
I have tabulated the results of the seventy-two varieties as 
suggested by Mr. Curtis. It is in this election we have Mr. 
Cranston’s list, and besides him we have the following nine 
murserymen :—Messrs. G. Paul & Son, Keynes & Co., Curtis, 
John Durbin, Davison, Piper, Cant, Turner, and G. Prince. There 
can be, I imagine, no question as to the value of these opinions. 
The amateurs, four in number, are scarcely inferior, comprising 
the Revs. C. P. Peach, Pochin, and Bulmer; and “ Hercules.” 
This table requires a word of explanation. The first column 
denotes the position of the Rose in the seventy-two election, 
the next column the position of the same Rose in the forty- 
eight election, so that it is easy to see at a glance the varieties 
of opinion ; then the name of the Rose; then follow four 
columns containing the first, second, third, and fourth-class 
votes, according as these are in the first or second twelve, the 
next twenty-four, or the second twenty-four; then the total 
votes. JI hope this makes the table clear, which I now present 
to your readers. 
FORTY-EIGHT VARIETIES, Amateurs. 4 |Nurserymen.¢ Sos No. SEVENTY-TWO 
Cha- 2 3 8s in VARIETIES. 3 
No. Name of Rose. racter. Age. Raiser’s Name. A CG g, |A* BF C* 8 Ge No. |48 var Name of Rose. ABCODA 
1 Marie Baumann H.P. 1863 Baumann 95). 10}1..0)..25;)/26 0: 0) 16 41 1 (fal Marie Baumann 14 00 0 i4 
2 Charles Lefebyre H.P. 1861 Lacharme One 1 0) -255| st 2 One 6, 41 2) U7 Alfred Colomb 14000 14 
3 La France H.P. 1868 Guillot, fils OMD) Gad 9551013) 2 V1 16 41 3 2 Charles Lefebvre 13.10 0 14 
4 Baronne de Rothschild H.P. 1867 Pernet 21 4 +O 25)13 1 2 16 41 A. 8 Maréchal Niel 13 001 1 
5 Louis Van Houtte H.P. 1869 Lacharme 14-6 4 24)10.3 3 Ie 40 5 (3 La France iG} eit al” (ial 
6 Etienne Levet H.P. 1871 Levet AS ste Oo -244|,10L ss 2s) 40 6 l4 Baronne de Rothschild} 12 1 1 0 14 
7 Alfred Colomb H.P. 1865 Lacharme 23 10),) O).93 |p 14ee QE Os IG: 39 7 6 Etienne Levet HT 2 OF Ty 14 
8 Maréchal Niel N. 1864 | ade 92% | Ug4:) 18/2) 0/15: |} 39. fF 8-| 9° ||] Hrancois Michelon 102201 
9 Francois Michelon H.P. 1871 Levet 12 19 +2):93:|'12) 3 oy 16 39 9: 5 Louis Van Houtte 743 0 14 
10 Marie Rady H.P. 1865 Fontaine 12) 75 4S g23: 3.6: 9% 16 39 10 12 Marquise de Castellane} 6 4 4 0 14 
11 Madame Victor Verdier H.P. 1868 KE, Verdier (feeb SGP} 3 5 8 16 39 11 25, Horace Vernet Dye De Gola 14 
12 Marquise de Castellane H.-P. 1869 Pernet T5L Ve 1P 29 SP 7a 6e 16: 38 Ferdinand de Lesseps 2 2) 2 
13 { Hugénie Verdier H.P. 1869 Guillot, fils 6 3 82o]| 2 5 3)4g]] 3g 12] 19 |} Exposition de Brie 210 O74 
Marie Finger H.P. 1873 Lacharme TL SEP aL Se 2 4) Maurice Bernardin 00 4 0 
14 Dr. Andry IP. 1864 E. Verdier 5.13) 60 24h ds de 18) 14/088: es. |e 10 Marie Rady 3 5, 6 0) 14 
15 Comtesse d@’Oxford H.P. 1869 Guillot, pére 3 14 7 24 Se'S2> 2013 37 14 17 Sénateur de Vaisse 3°45 2 14 
16 Duke of Edinburgh H.P. 1868 Paul & Son 2.-\8 AL, 21 35. 7% 15 36 9 15 11 Madame Victor Verdier| 3 3 7 1 14 
17 Sénateur Vaisse H.P. 1859 Guillot, pere 35 Siedt 22 34 (6 13 39 fag 13 { Eugénie Verdier 2) 3) 3) 14 
18 Dchss. de Vallombrosa H.P. 1875 Schwartz (?) 4 3 14 21 DEI) Unies 30 | Marie Finger 0° 2'°3 0 
Ferdinand de Lesseps H.P. 1869 HE. Verdier 2y 9.448 24 5) 17} 14 Dr. Andry Legh top ly 14 
19 {potion de Brie H.P. 1865 Granger eyo 20 Te Osp alae 5) 35 18 22 Xavier Olibo LG aes 4: 
Maurice Bernardin H.p. 1861 Granger 0 0 3) 24 19 18 Dehss. de Vallombrosa| 1 310 O 14 
20 Capitaine Christy H.P. 1873 Lacharme 3 5 13°21] 1 4 9 144] 35 7 20) I6 Duke of Edinburgh 0671 14 
21 Reynolds Hole HP. 1873 Paul & Son 4 “4,12, 20) 4,5; 4 13 33° 21 23 Margt. de St. Amand 4540 13 
22 Xavier Olibo H.P. 1864 Lacharme CE AOy De P10 Qhd- 16; 13 33 22 21 Reynolds Hole Oye Bs 2b 9) a 163 
23 Maret.deSt.Amand uP. 1864 Sansal BIS “ETON” 6.2: 14 12, 32 | 23 28 Catherine Mermet 16 4 2 13 
24 Mons. E. Y. Teas H.p. 1875 E. Verdier 3.56 dny20 24 6 12 32 24 24 Mons. E. Y. Teas 1 4% 1 13 
25 Horace Vernet H.P. 1£63 Guillot, fils Gye i erb al) 6,523, .4,, 12 31 2 33 Comtesse de Serenye 145 3 13 
26 Camille Bernardin up. 1865 Gantreau ZENO 5s LZ: OW 5s  % 12 29 26 30 Star of Waltham OM 2) Were 13 
27 =P erre Notting H.P. 1863 Portemer Bo2 ICTs) ) Ve F08 12 23 § 27] 40 Madame Lacharme 0067 13 
28 Catherine Mermet tr. 1869 Guillot, fils Dien Owls 2 6, 2 10 27 28 37 Souvenir d’Elise 3) Bi tones 12 
29 Duke of Wellington H.P. 1864 Granger Te AOE ON) (Q REVUE NOS 27 29 | 38-39! Mons. Noman 15 4 2 12 
30 Star of Waltham H.P. 1875 W. Paul 1 P93+ Tk 15 ac DG) ota DE 26 30 31 John Hopper i oD F4g062"12 
31 John Hopper up. 1862 Ward Ti & 5 12H 18s|| Ove yar FS 26 9 31) 46 Beauty of Waltham 015 6 12 
32 Emilie Hausburg uP. 1868 Leyeéque De POE NG AT Bedok a aS 25 32 15 Comtesse d’Oxford BO15 2p IT 
33 Comtesse de Serenye H.P. 1875 Lacharme TY 40 Sei 3r| 44s 4 19 25 f 33] 43 Marie Van Houtte 23 3 3 1 
34 Dupuy Jamain H.P. 1868 Jamain MeOH Ladsy |) OS TO. 25 faq | (44 Be Ht SueSeror Ly: 
35 Edouard Morren ILP. 1869 Granger 1.0% 69), 14a| 0-3.) 3416.) 23 {45 | Devoniensis 
36 Fisher Holmes IP. 1865 HE. Verdier 0 3 9 12] 0 2 8 10]| 22 § 35) 58 | Niphetos d244 
37 Souvenir d’Elise vr. 1855 Marest I 15) G12 BBE 129) 21 36 | (26 Camille Bernardin LORS 01 
38, ( Souvenir d’un Ami v. 1846 BelotDefougére | 2 4 6 12) 0 3 5 8 20 | 37 |} 20 Capitaine Christy 1592418) 10) 11 
39 | Monsieur Noman H.P. 1866 Guillot, pére Deedee Gaplly| |b dee Ayia 09) 20 #38] 34 Dupuy Jamain 063 2 11 
40 Madame Lacharme iP. 1872 Lacharme OMS: Saeki: 04 3r 6 9 20 739} 36 Fisher Holmes Wo ower. aal 
41 PrinceCamilledeRohan H.p. 1863 E. Verdier Ley 280718 Oi .15)) -6 19 AO. 35 Edouard Morren 02 5 411 
42 Victor Verdier H.P. 1859 Lacharme 0 6 10 16) O12 1,53 19; J. 41 | 27 Pierre Notting 006 5 lL 
43 Marie Van Houtte vr. 1871 Ducher a Sta lege Le, LSE i2is 9 G 18 42 32 Emilie Hausburg 2,3 3 2 10 
44 jbeveniense T. 1838 Foster ON 3e Vet 119) |)) BiBut ailing 13 ft 4g | (38 Lat E 0451 10 
45 \Duchesse de Morny —_‘1L.P. Ty $2) (of p10pl Wet4 389 Belly 18 139; ,| ;Souvenir dian, Ami 
46 Beauty of Waltham Hp. 1862 W. Paul Ty A Ge Us Ole 6s 67i| 18. hae he ae Victor Verdier 0 22 6 10 
47 Malle. Thérése Levet H.P. 1866 Levet DIO Ve et sy|(1 00) “Sie=3 16 #45 | 70 Elie Morel 0 0 6 4 10 
48 Sir Garnet Wolscley H.P. 1875 Cranston Outlsy Rapes 0.33" 5) 8 16 9 46) 51 Abel Carriére 3231 9 
49 Hippolyte Jamain H.P. 1874 Lacharme EON) ee aki) Oe Dey Atel 15 47 29, Duke of Wellington Lge tf 9 
50 Abel Grand H.P. 1865 Damaizin de 2p F8r 1 00, 4 4 15 48 (44 hésenid OO Aone 
51 Abel Carriere HP. 1875 ©. Verdier 0 2/4 6] 3.1 4.8] 14 45) je Duchesse deMorny 
52 Lord Macaulay HP. 1863 Ward 2-0 7 9] 0.0 5. 5)) 14 $49) 56 Mrs. C. Wood 0234 9 
53 Annie Wood U.P. 1866 E. Verdier 4 010 11} OL 2 38)| 14 J 40) 49 | Hippolyte Jamain o216 9 
54 Marie Cointet H.P. 1872 Guillot, fils 0 5 4 9]| 00 5 5} 14 J 51} 53 | Annie Wood o135 9 
55, Duc de Rohan HP. 1861 Leréque 1 2 710] 00 2 2|| 12 $52] 54 | Marie Cointet 0054 9 
56. Mrs. C. Wood H.P. 1861 E. Verdier On 03), Ay 7s) 0, 2a5 Be Sell p12 hos. 52 Lord Macaulay, 0036 9 
57 Mad. Hippolyte Jamain H.P. 1871 Garcon UPS BORO Outs oot 12 ff 54 Général Jacqueminot 0027 9 
58° Niphetos mn 1 0 3 4/ 11 5 7@]} I 55} 50 | Abel Grand 0233 8 
59. Gloire de Dijon DT. 1853 Jacotot 1 5 511} 00 0 O}] 11 f 66] 60 | Jean Liabaud 0o224 8 
60 Jean Liabaud H.P. 1875 Liabaud ETE NS Oe Sato: 11 57 48 Sir Garnet Wolseley OL > 2 8 
él {Baran de Bonstetten H.P. 1871 Liabaud 1 1 429} 9 1 2,4)! 41 P58] 1 | {Baron de Bonstetten O11 4 g 
Monsieur Boncenne HP. 1864 Liabaud 0 0 3 O10) Lie ( Monsieur Boncenne 0002 
42 Le Hayre H.P. Eude 0 2-7 9! 00 2 2]| 11 | 59] 62 | Le Havre 0. 0. 4.4.8 
63 Devienne Lamy H.P. 1868 Levéque ROE BEN Oey BG 10 9 60 | ( Princess Beatrice 0026 8 
64 Marguerite Brassac IP. 1875 Brassac Opie 2h Hoi WO)aOsn 4a: 9 4 61 | 57 Madame H. Jamain 0026 8 
s i Aloplenien H.P. 1869 Laxton OP Seiya t2h|\ | a OP alee 9 §.62| 41 Prince C. de Rohan 0} 0), S545) 7 
le Lyonnaise Tv. 169 Levet ah aoa Depeiec: Hea} Ue) ats 9 65 = 
67 Royal Standard wb. 1874 Turner 16 8 al ee Balls PSF lf6s, |i Annie Zaxton OF Oat ati 
68 Miss Hassard HP. 1875 Turner Oj! Joidpo Au) On day ise YS 8 [64 | 64 | Marguerite Brassac | 1 0 3 2. 6 
69 Dukeof Connaught 4H.P. 1876 Paul & Son OO) dey Tes Oe Sh tone 8 § 65) 69 Duke of Connaught (mp nchsal 
70 Elie Morel H.P. 1867 Liabaud WW Sw Baill O06 B 8 | 66 Marie L. Pernet OTS 1A Seats, 
71 Rey. J.B.M.Camm  4u.P. 1875 Turner OVO) ay PL || Leto varie 7 | 67 Sultan of Zanzibar Oy 0) 2x4 
72 Anguste Rigotard LP. Schwartz OO BP) OB PS 7 Tes ( Duchesse de Caylus 0006 6 
69 Alba Rosea 000 i} 6 
lestaanae Bravy ooo 
70 | 63 Deyienne Lamy 0; (3 ae 6 
71 | 72 Auguste Rigotard 0212 5 
Tale 1s ules Margottin (saat) wl Se, OA 
Mdle. Thérése Levet 
eee 
-y An eee ie anes, 
