JOURNAL OF HORTICULTURE 
AND COTTAGE GARDENER, 
[ October 31, 1878. 
13. Madame Victor Verdier 19. Thérése Levet 65, Madame Prosper Langier 69. Triomphe de France 
14, Comtesse d’Oxford 20. Princess Mary of Cambridge 66. Mdlle. Bonnaire 70. Cheshunt Hybrid 
15. Abel Grand 21. Frangois Michelon 67. Reynolds Hole 71. John Hopper 
16, Gloire de Dijon 22. Duc de Wellington 68, Jean Lambert 72, Niphetos 
17. Louis Van Houtte 23. Marguerite de St. Amand Tos = eye 
18. Dupuy Jamain 24. Eugenie Verdier { My. BR. G. BAKER, Heavitree, Devon. 
25. . 7 t 37. Star of Walth 1. Marie Banmann 7. Marquise de Castellane 
ee Eade. So Stan cba bam 2. Charles Lefebvre 8. Maréchal Niel 
97. Le Havre 39. Victor Verdier 3. Alfred Colomb 9. Baronne de Rothschild 
28. Thomas Methven 40. Madame Lacharme 4, Marie Rady 10. Camille Bernardin 
29. Marie Van Houtte 41, Fisher Holmes 5. Frangois Michelon 11. Monsieur E. Y. Teas 
30, Annie Wood 42, Monsieur E. Y. Teas 6. Marie Van Houtte 12, La France 
31. Capitaine Christy 43. Reynolds Hole 13. Monsieur Noman 19. Catherine Mermet 
32. Duchesse de Vallombrosa 44. Monsieur Caillat 14, Marguerite de St. Amand 20. Duc de Wellington 
33. Souvenir d’un Ami 45. Duchesse de Morny 15. Souvenir d’un Ami 21. Madame Bravy 
34. Souvenir d’E£lise 46. Maurice Bernardin 16. Dr. Andry 22. Sénateur Vaisse 
35. Sénateur Vaisse 47. Souvenir de Malmaison 17. Souvenir d’Elise Vardon 23. Hippolyte Jamain 
36. Sir Garnet Wolseley 48. Edouard Morren 18. Abel Carriere 24, Xavier Olibo 
49. Annie Laxton 61. La Rosiére 25. Maurice Bernardin 37. Duchesse de Vallombrosa 
50. Beauty of Waltham 62. Madame Charles Crapelet 26. Abel Grand 38. Caroline Kuster 
51. Boule de Neige 63. Maréchal Vaillant 27. Horace Vernet 39. Prince Camille de Rohan 
52. Céline Forestier 64. Marquise de Mortemart 28. Louis Van Houtte 40. Edouard Morren 
53. Cheshunt Hybrid 65. Monsieur Woolfield 29. Madame Victor Verdier 41. Reynolds Hole 
54, Catherine Mermet 66. Mrs. Baker 30. Duke of Edinburgh 42. Madame Prosper Langier 
55. Duke of Edinburgh 67. Prince Camille de Rohan 31. Jules Margottin 43, Comtesse d’Oxford 
56, Elie Morel 68. Pierre Notting 32. Centifolia Rosea 44, Baronne de Bonstetten 
57. Hippolyte Jamain 69. Royal Standard 33. Marchioness of Exeter 45, Fisher Holmes 
58. Général Jacqueminot 70. Sultan of Zanzibar 34, Devoniensis 46. Lord Macaulay 
59. Francois Louvat 71. Xavier Olibo 35. Comte de Raimbaud 47. Sultan of Zanzibar 
60. Jules Margottin 72. Wilson Saunders 36. Monsieur Gabriel Tournier 48. Mrs. Charles Wood 
ne ‘ hs 49. Sir Garnet Wolseley 61. Niphetos 
Rev. E. N. Pocuin, Barkby Vicarage, Leicestershire. 50. Marquise de Mortemart 62. Mrs. Baker 
1. Maréchal Niel 7. Marguerite Brassac 51. Madame Georges Schwartz 63. Auguste Neumann 
2. Alfred Colomb 8. Madame Victor Verdier 52. Jean Liabaud 64. Mdlle. Marie Cointet 4 
3. Charles Lefebvre 9. Marquise de Castellane 53. Le Havre 65, Madame Hippolyte Jamain 
4, Marie Baumann 10. Malle. Marie Rady 54, Mdlle. Eugénie Verdier 66. Victor Verdier 
5. La France 11. Duc de Wellington 55. Duchesse de Caylus 67. Duke of Connaught 
6. Baronne de Rothschild 12. Etienne Levet 56, Souvenir de Paul Neyron 68. Miss Hassard 
ae we z 57. Auguste Rigotard 69. Comtesse de Serenye 
18. Louis Van Houtte 19. Sénateur Vaisse 58. Madame Lacharme 70, Madame de Montchayeau 
14. Dr. Andry 20. Marguerite de St. Amand 5 7 A 
of 7 i Zl 59. Magna Charta 71. Etienne Levet 
15. Horace Vernet 21. Edouard Morren 60. Beauty of Waltham 72. Prince Arthur 
16. Monsieur E. Y. Teas 22, Emilie Hausburg pete e Ras i 
17. Victor Verdier 23. Dupuy Jamain I haye only named one of the three (Ferdinand de Lesseps, Maurice Ber- 
18. Duke of Edinburgh 24, Baron de Bonstetten nardin, and Exposition de Brie), as they are so much alike. 
25. D se de Vallombrosa ots ir d’Elis . + 4s CLiiy 
26. Duchess deve ete ot Pera Mr. Bulmer in his list has rather enlarged on his idea of 
27. Catherine Mermet 39. John Hopper last year as to similar Roses ; and although in his soil he sees 
He neato teen if Bouse Ga eae less similarity in Alba Rosea and Madame Bravy than some 
. Se xXfore . eine du Midi 7 KY . 7 
30. Comtesse de Serenye 42. Monsieur Noman do—and in, this 1 confess that with my small experience oF 
31. Lord Macaulay 43. Capitaine Christy them I incline to his view—yet about several of them he has 
32. Mrs. C. Wood 44, Camille Bernardin no hesitation in considering them so similar as to be either 
33. Fisher Holmes 45. Reynolds Hole Cesar or Pompey according to the fancy of the namer. Before 
34. Star of Waltham 46. Marie Finger in . 
aaeDeronionsis AT RSGirent emt another exhibition election we may know more about Mar- 
36. Pierre Notting 48. Annie Wood guerite Brassac and its similarity to Charles Lefebvre (to me the 
49. Madame C. Crapelet 61. Madame Clemence Joigneaux | latter is many shades the darker), and La Rosiére and Prince 
Be pecngrend a 62. Auphetos Camille de Rohan. It strikes me these may possibly be added 
ae bie relnandldedessebs ee Veena ocheume to the list of similar Roses, which for purposes of election may 
53. Princess Beatrice 65" MariesvaniHoutte be considered identical. I now give Mr. Bulmer’s list, pre- 
eee pususte Rigotard 66. ledene Hippolyte Jamain mising that in the bracketed Roses the vote is given to that 
. Paul Neyron 67. Gloire de Dijon whi i 
56. Prince Camille de Rohan 68. Sir Garnet Wolseley chiis named first. 
ae Hipelyee aman oy Contos eee Rey. C. H. BULMER, Credenhill Rectory, Hereford. 
. Duchesse de Morny 0. Baron Gonella 2 - 
Sou aalderRohan 71, Duchesse de Caylus oy Alfred Colomb 7. Marquise de Castellane 
60. Thérése Levet alk GomtesseldeuNadaliae 2. Marie Baumann 8. Comtesse d’Oxford __ 
‘i oe 3 { Charles Lefebyre 9, { Mdlle. Eugénie Verdier 
s . E */ Marguerite Brassac “* / Mdlle. Marie Finger 
Mr. DuRBIN, Englishcombe Rosery, Bath. ASTER ATES TOMmousavanwelontte 
1. Abel Carriére 7. Francois Michelon 5, Etienne Leyet 11. Fran¢ois Michelon 
2, Alfred Colomb 8. La France 6. Baronne de Rothschild 12. Marechal Niel 
3. Capitaine Christy 9. Marie Baumann 2 i 17. Emilie H - 
4, Charles Lefebvre 10. Sénateur Vaisse Tbs Oma emai 8. ina ep ans eure, 
; : 14, Marie Rady 18. Xayier Olibo 
5. Comtesse d’Oxford 11. Maréchal Niel N i oh 
a 5 i : 15. Dr. Andry 19. Duke of Edinburg 
6. Etienne Levet 12. Mdlle. Marie Rady Abel Grand (Edouard Morren 
13. Marie L. Pernet 19. Monsieur E. Y. Teas 16. | Marguerite de St. Amand 20.< Jules Margottin; 
14. Comtesse de Serenye 20. Sir Garnet Wolseley Princess Mary of Cambridge (L’Esmeralda 
15. Fisher Holmes 21. Catherine Mermet 1, Monsieur N 34, Camille B rdin 
16. Hippolyte Jamain 22. Star of Waltham an Jeans 35, ae TaeEne x 
17. Mdue. Marie Finger 23. Xavier Olibo TRxpositi ‘| Emily 
a 4 : Exposition de Brie 36. Emily Laxton 
18. Madame Victor Verdier 24, Louis Van Houtte of Ferdinand de Lesseps 37. Marquise de Gibot 
25. Baronne de Rothschild 37. Marguerite Brassac *) Sir Garnet Wolseley 38. John Hopper 
26. Abel Grand 38. Marguerite de Castellane Maurice Bernardin 39. Malle. Marie Cointet 
27. Camille Bernardin 39. Mrs. Baker 24, Marie Van Houtte 40. Madame Prosper Langier 
28. Dr. Andry 40. Oxonian 25, Jean Soupert 41, Capitaine Christy 
29. Duchesse de Vallombrosa 41. Paul Neyron 26. Due de Wellington 42, Duchesse de Vallombrosa 
30. Duke of Connaught 42. Perfection de Lyon 27. Horace Vernet 43, Comtesse de Serenye 
31. Duke of Edinburgh 43. Rey. J. B. M. Camm 28. Le Havre 44, Elie Morel 
32. Francois Lacharme 44. Sophie Coquerelle 29. Monsieur BE, Y. Teas 45, Madame Lacharme 
33. John Stuart Mill 45, Devoniensis 30. Madame Victor Verdier 46. Catherine Mermet 
34, Lady Mary Keith 46. Perle des Jardins 31. Beauty of Waltham 47. Souvenir d’Elise 
35, Louise Peyronny 47, Madame Willermoz 32. Star of Waltham 48, Madame Caroline Kuster 
36. Marguerite de St. Amand 48. Duc de Montpensier 33. Sénateur Vaisse 
49. Abbé Bramerel 57. Emilie Hausburg 49. Reynolds Hole 55, Lord Macaulay 
50. Anna de Diesbach 58. Ferdinand de Lesseps 50. { La Rosiére 56. Comte de Raimbaud 
51. Annie Wood 59. General Jacqueminot * | Prince Camille de Rohan 57. Baron Hausmann 
£2, Avocat Duvivier 60. Gloire de Vitry 51 Monsieur Boncenne 58. Thomas Mills 
53. Bessie Johnson 61. Horace Vernet * | Baron de Bonstetten 59. Devienne Lamy 
54, Duc de Rohan 62. Jean Liabaud 52. Pierre Notting 60. Clotilde Rolland 
55, Dupuy Jamain 63. Jules Margottin 53. Sultan of Zanzibar 61. Général Jacqueminot 
56. Elie Morel 
. Madame Clemence Joigneaax 
54, Fisher Holmes 
62. Mrs. Baker 
