f 



I 



I 



air 



'""H experi. 



^ic doctrine, 

 ^y kind were 

 ch had been 

 ided the 

 ad been pre- 

 Iphuric acid, 

 md Scliwaim 

 ertain reser- 

 hen calcined 



> 





ccess 



to the 



solution of 

 1 have been 



influence 



\n)'. 



at ) 



joct was 



'J 



a 



CO 



newep 



I 



- ^ 



m 



sp 



ite 



of» 







THE BEGINNINGS OF LIFE. 



263 



about twelve years ago. Since this time, and in France 

 more especially, the truth or falsity of the doctrine of 



r 



^^.spontaneous generation^ has formed the subject of a 

 most vigorous discussion. Its renewal was initiated in 

 858 by the communication of a paper by M. Pouchet 



I 



sur 



Proto-or 



les Sciences of Paris, entitled ^Note 

 ;anismes vegetaux et animaux nes 

 spontanement dans Tair artificiel et dans le gaz oxy- 

 gene." The views and experiments of M. Pouchet 

 were warmly repudiated by men so distinguished as 

 MM. Milne-Edwards, de Quatrefages, Claude Bernard, 

 Dumas, Payen, and Lacaze Duthiers. Nevertheless, 

 Professor Mantegazza very shortly afterwards also com- 

 municated to the Academy of Sciences the results of 

 his researches upon the generation of infusoria, which 



he had previously laid before an Italian academy in 



85 



The conclusions at which he had arrived agreed 



t> 



and in 



almost perfectly with those of M. Pouchet; 

 the following year the latter published his treatise on 

 ^ Heterogenic ^,' in which much new matter was added 

 in support of his doctrines. But it would be in vain 

 for us now to attempt to follow out all the intricacies 

 of the discussions which have taken place since this 

 tim2 2. Many of the most interesting points will be 



^ To this treatise we must refer those also who desire a more com- 

 plete historical sketch than we have deemed it necessary to give. 



^ This has been attempted by M. Pennetier, in a work entitled * L'Ori- 

 gine de la Vie/ which, in addition to a sketch of the later stages of the 



r 



controversy up to the year 1869, contains a very complete list of works 

 and papers on the whole subject, arranged in chronological order. 



\ 



