WHITWELL: WEST YORKSHIRE RECORDS AND NOTES. 33 
These are quoted for the sake of a note with the 
Cronkley Fell specimen—‘ Supposed to be different from 
the Arncliffe one, as it flowers later.’ 
Rosa spinosissima L. Page 
Alpine Woods near Sete: June 1833. 7. 
Lynn Gill, 1842 
Rosa involuta Sm. var. : Blecst Page 225. 
L. 
Ingleton. A Feizor. ‘per &. Clapham. 
Rosa canina var. dumetorum Thuill. Page 228. 
uck Ha’ Brow, Stackhouse 7. 
Rosa canina var. Borreri Woods. Page 230. 
R. ‘Comm MS. 
on.’ 
Cave Ha’ Wood (as inodora). #1. 
Rosa arvensis Huds. (marked ‘arvensis, Anglict.’). Page 230. 
Heselton Gill. Z. 
‘LYTHRACE:. 
Lythrum salicaria L. Page 233 
R. Nappa. #. Near Giggleswick. J/S. Within three miles 
A. 
Feb. 1893. 
of Settle. Marked as such, Mr. J. G. Baker informs 
me, in a catalogue supplied to Mr. Watson. 
‘Malham Tarn: J. Tatham ’—is entered in the ‘Flora of 
West Yorkshire,’ by transcript from Miall and Carrington’s 
‘Flora.’ It is strange that no mention of Malham Tarn 
is found in any of Mr. T.’s own notes, and that there is 
no specimen in his herbarium. 
The only record of the plant for the Tarn is in the 
M. and C. ‘Flora,’ and the only authority given is 
Mr. Tatham’s. Professor Miall informs me that it was 
taken from a marked list sent to him by Mr. Tatham. 
Mr. Walter Morrison, the courteous owner of the 
Tarn House estate, has favoured me with a letter in 
which he states that the Purple Loosestrife is well known 
to him from its beauty on some of the reaches of the 
Thames, and that he has never seen it at the Tarn. Itis 
not known at the Tarn, either, to his gardener, Mr. T. 
Coulthard, who is well acquainted with the local plants. 
Professor Miall himself, and Mr. William West of 
Bradford, both inform me that they have not met with it 
in the locality. Mr. F. A. Lees has not seen it there. 
I am compelled therefore to the opinion that some 
mistake was made in connection with the original marked 
list, and that the species must still be considered as 
Cc 
